Outside of the low blows and the ref, did Mares win that fight?

Vote and discuss.

 

I consider myself a pretty objective scorer (ignore the avatar, simply showing my support for this bout), here is my scorecard:

Agebko-Mares

8-10 (knockdown - actually a slip )
10-9
9-10
10-9
10-9 (very close)
9-10 (very close)
9-10 (very close)
10-9 (very close)
10-9
10-9
9-10 (Mares credited with a knockdown (low-blow), but clearly lost round - 9-10 due to this)
10-9

114-113 Agbeko

Notes: 30 low blows by Mares

Now the scorecard without the shite ref:

Agebko-Mares

9-10
10-9
9-10
10-9
10-9 (very close)
9-10 (very close)
9-10 (very close)
10-9 (very close)
10-9
10-9
10-9
10-9

116-112 Agbeko

I can see it being a bit closer, but a clear win for Agbeko without the referee.

 

No.

Without any deductions he should have lost (or Agbeko retained with a draw).

With the appropriate points deductions there is no possible way for him to have won enough rounds to take it.

 

No. I gave to 11th to mares 10-9 because i thought he really
won the round, but i scored the fight to agbeko 114-113. I
wrote down every round, and never penalized mares when mora should
have been. I thought agbeko hurt mares several times with the right
and landed that jab solidly. Mares body work was terrible so it didn't
count. With a credible ref, who by the way wouldn't have called the
KD in the 1st, agbeko would've won handily. He's the better fighter clearly. In a rematch on non mexican grounds with a white ref, agbeko
stops mares.

 

TS,

are you serious or trollin?

 

you can't even score this fight at all, it becomes an unfair moot point with this many low blows. It undoubtably changed the outcome which in turn changed the scoring and not just in round eleven. I'm talking about all the low blows before that.

 

I didn't get to watch the fight and won't be able to for about three more weeks, unless of course it is uploaded onto Youtube. Just trying to get everyone's opinion on it. I did read IB's RBR, though. Seemed as if there was more of an outcry because of the ref and him not counting the low blows. No one claimed that Mares was not scoring or anything like that.

 

Mares won but it is a tainted victory.

 

So is the hate directed towards Mares or GBP and Mora? Or is it all three?

 

Mora
GBP
Mares

In that order.

Mora for taking the bribe, GBP for offering the bride and Mares for not being able to keep his punches up and making a ****** excuse at the end.

 

Agbeko looked like **** from the get go, but how can anyone say how the fight would have developed when he got fouled multiple times each round. Honestly, nice a guy as Mares seems, he should have been DQ'd.

 

Ye he looked crap in round 1, but that was the only round he looked bad in. atsch

 

The low blows were flowing from the opening round. I didn't bother to score the fight, but it's impossible to say just how badly the blows affected Agbeko's performance. It's the reason why an immediate rematch is an absolute must.

 

No, he looked bad a lot, plodded most of the fight, swung wildly, couldn't connect an overhand right to save his life. But he was fouled terribly. Mares should have been DQ'd. :good

 

Not how I saw it. Had Agbeko winning more rounds WITH and WITHOUT the awful reffing.