Most numbers of atg beaten? Pac or Floyd

Pac- barrera, morales, jmm, dela hoya, mosley
If cotto wins a middleweight title he deserve to be an atg

Floyd- dela hoya, jmm, mosley and who else?

 

just about right. 5 to 3.

 

I dont consider mosley an atg and the marquez win has little meaning for floyd, the only atg he beat was Oscar and im pretty sure a few years ago everyone thought he was only a hof boxer because of his losses, yet now I even see people rank Oscar above morales and barrera.
Imo its 3-1: pac has barrera,morales,marquez vs floyds oscar.
Oscar win gets pac little to no credit despite the risk because it was at 147 and how Oscar looked.

 

Cotto is atg if he beat sergio martinez

 

jmm counts? pre-fight jmm was already ****ed in weight and we all knew it was a complete mismatch right from the outset because of this.

 

agree but it's a big IF. Cotto is HOF though.

 

Castillo is surely hall of fame worthy, maybe better.

 

We know that's not going to happen. Cottoe made the decision to never step with a Slick fighter after seeing what Bernard did to his fellow boriqua Tito. Miguel is determined to never experience the same fate.

 

Cottoe baarly a G led alone an ATG :rofl the mined of a pacturd atsch

 

off names only.

pac: mab, jmm, morales, mosley, oscar
floyd: oscar, jmm, mosley

 

Hatton?

He was lineal champion for 4 years.

 

Baldomir is the GOAT.

 

I think hatton will make the hall but he aint atg worthy IMO. he never hit top p4p spot and his resume isn't worthy enough to compensate IMO.

 

Hof. But not atg

 

castillo I was thinking about but he's a level beneath IMO