If Hopkins beats Dawson is he Top 3 P4P?

Top 6 - 8.

These five have been more dominating than him.

Manny Pacquiao
Sergio Martinez
Nonito Donaire
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Wladimir Klitschko

 

I would put him over marquez and maybe wlad.
I have hopkins at 7 now

 

Prolly around 6-7

 

I say:

Pacquiao
Mayweather
Martinez
Donaire
W. Klit
B-Hop

 

Certainly not top 3, the LHW division is pretty weak nowadays so A top P4P guy would have to utterly dominate the division.
He might just edge the top 10 imo.

 

donaire only has 3 good wins and never fights.i hardly think he deserves to be ranked above hopkins

 

He might just edge Martinez to fourth sport for me. Sexy Sergio's big wins (Williams, alcoholic Pavlik) are slightly overrated IMO.

 

Donaire had 6 fights since 2009. His record is 6-0-0, with 5 KOs.
Hopkins had 4 fights since 2009. His record is 3-0-1, with 0 KO.

 

yeah but who are the other 3 in that 6? nobodies

he never capitalizes on his momentum.the fact it has taken him 7 months since his destruction of montiel to even schedule a fight is a joke

 

I would say yes, but have no problems with the #4 spot either. He is taking on the young bucks at the top of their division. These are quality wins in fights he was expected to lose.

 

where did you have pascal in your p4p ranking for beating diaconu twice, beating dawson and then drawing with hopkins?

where do you have froch in your rankings for beating pascal, taylor, dirrel, abraham, and johnson?

 

For me its hard to put together a top 10 in order but he is in it.

 

He would go back in my current top ten, which he isn't in. I swear people can't separate an amazing accomplishment for a 46-year-old man and an amazing accomplishment for anyone else.

How can anyone even compare Donaire's work to Hopkins over their last three fights? Montiel is so much better than Pascal, and he was obliterated in two to Hopkins' decision, viciously destroying Syd is better than a hard luck draw with Pascal after being put down a few times, and Hernan Marquez isn't great but he has got to be better than an utterly shot to **** RJJ coming down in weight immediately after a first round stoppage loss to Danny Green. Especially looking at what either has done since. I mean, this is a current p4p list, meaning where they're at right now. Not an accomplishments list.

 

i disagree.montiel was tiny compared to donaire and was 33 i think? or maybe it was 32...anyway i think he and pascal match up in terms of signifigance

pascal,especially on foreign soil with a belt on the line is 10 times better than the sydorenko victory

but yes that rjj win is worthless