Bad Judging, Promoters, Refs, etc. Thread IS BACK (2015 Edition)

January 4th, 2013:
Fight: Jonathan Gonzalez-Derek Ennis
Judges: Rich Green, Toby Tamarkin
Network: ESPN 2's Friday Night Fights
Promoter: Richard Dobal (Bad Dog Productions), Warriors Boxing

Fight: Rances Barthelemy-Arash Usmanee
Judges: Rick Bay, Rich Green, and Valarie Dorsett
Network: ESPN 2's Friday Night Fights
Promoter: Richard Dobal (Bad Dog Productions), Warriors Boxing

January 11th, 2013:
Fight: Ronny Rios-Rico Ramos
Judge: Fritz Werner
Network: Showtime (ShoBox)
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

January 19th, 2013:
Fight: Juan Carlos Burgos-Rocky Martinez
Judge: Tony Paolillo and John Signorile
Network: HBO (B.A.D)
Promoter: Top Rank

January 26th, 2013:
Fight: Jesus Soto Karass-Selcuk Aydin
Judge: Richard Ocasio
Network: Showtime (Showtime Championship Boxing)
Promoter: Golden Boy Promtions/Ahmet Oner

February 1st, 2013:
Fight: Carlos Molina-Cory Spinks
Referee: Celestino Ruiz
Network: ESPN 2's Friday Night Fights
Promoter: Warriors Boxing (Don King was a promoter in this as well, but his fighter, Cory Spinks, wasn't getting any of the calls his way)

February 1st, 2013:
Fight: Artur Szpilka-Mike Mollo
Referee: Celestino Ruiz
Network: ESPN3 (Special bonus coverage of Friday Night Fights)
Promoter: Warriors Boxing

Februrary 8th, 2013:
Fight: Sonny Bill Williams-Frans Botha
Network: Main Event
Promoter: Khoder Nasser
Why it's on here: This is a special fight in which corruption was taken to the next level. The fight was scheduled for 12 rounds. Everywhere you looked this fight was was scheduled for 12 rounds. After Williams was badly hurt and on the verge of getting put to sleep, the promoters, officials, handlers of the fight changed it to 10 rounds. Williams ended up winning a 10 round decision, which was fine if it was scheduled for 10 rounds, but it wasn't. This fight was a 12 round fight, but the officials changed it to 10 rounds. Unbelievable amount of corruption and if this was in the United States this would have gotten much bigger coverage. As it is, it was talked about for a couple of minutes and everybody moved on. A damn shame. A real ****ing shame that Botha got robbed. That not only robbed Botha of a win, but us the fans, were robbed of a fantastic come-from-behind KO victory.

February 16th, 2013:
Fight: Jonathan Romero-Alejandro Lopez
Judge: James Bagshaw
Network: Televisa
Promoter: Zanfer Promotions

February 23rd, 2013:
Fight: Badou Jack-Don Mouton
Judges: N/A (Probably won't ever know just because it was off TV.)
Network: Undercard of Showtime's Ishe Smith-K9
Promoter: The Money Team

February 23rd, 2013:
Fight: Ishe Smith-Cornelius Bundrage
Judge: Dave Hess
Network: Showtime
Promoter: Golden Boy

February 23rd, 2013:
Fight: Vyacheslav Glazkov-Malik Scott
Judges: John McKay and Julie Lederman
Network: NBC Sports Network
Promoter: Kathy Duva, Main Events

March 1st, 2013:
Fight: Evgeny Gradovich-Billy Dib
Judges: Don Ackerman (114-112 Dib), Don Trella, and Glenn Feldman (both had Gradovich winning 114-112, but their scorecards were ****. So, they deserve a place here.)
Referee: Eddie Claudio
Network: ESPN 2's Friday Night Fights
Promoter: Curtis Jackson SMS Promotions/Lou DiBella.

March 23rd, 2013:
Fight: Adrian Granados-Kermit Cintron
Judges: John McCarthy, Robert Hecko
Network: ESPN 2's Friday Night Fights
Promoter: 8 Count Productions, Blue Wave, and Warrior's Boxing

March 23rd, 2013:
Fight: Don George-David Lopez
Judges: John McCarthy, Mike Fitzgerald
Network: ESPN 2's Friday Night Fights
Promoter: 8 Count Productions, Blue Wave, and Warrior's Boxing

March 30th, 2013:
Fight: Zsolt Erdei-Denis Grachev
Judges: Terry O'Connor, Philippe Verbeke
Promoter: Lou DiBella

March 30th, 2013:
Fight: Tony Bellew-Isaac Chilemba
Judges: Eddie Pappe (I'll mention Fabian Guggenheim as well, he had the fight scored a draw. Reasonable, but still...)
Network: Sky Sports
Promoter: Matchroom

April 6th, 2013:
Fight: Roman Martinez-Diego Magdaleno
Judges: Levi Martinez, Michael Pernick
Network: HBO2
Promoter: Top Rank

April 6th, 2013:
Fight: Juan Francisco Estrada-Brian Viloria
Judge: Levi Martinez
Network: HBO2
Promoter: Top Rank

April 13th, 2013:
Fight: Guillermo Rigondeaux-Nonito Donaire
Judges: John Stewart, Tom Schreck
Network: HBO
Promoter: Top Rank

April 20th, 2013:
Fight: Saul Alvarez-Austin Trout
Judges: Stanley Christodoulou, Oren Shellenberger
Network: Showtime
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

May 4th, 2013:
Fight: J'Leon Love-Gabriel Rosado
Judges: Herb Santos, Dave Moretti (Glenn Trowbridge deserves a mention as well. He did score the fight for Rosado, but still only by a point. At least he got it right, though.)
Network: HBO
Promoter: Mayweather/Golden Boy Promotions

May 24th, 2013:
Fight: Tony Bellew-Isaac Chilemba
Judges: Franco Ciminale, Victor Loughlin, Daniel Van de Wiele
Network: Sky Sports
Promoter: Matchroom

June 22nd, 2013:
Fight: Adrien Broner-Paulie Malignaggi
Judges: Tom Miller (he scored it 115-113 for Paulie.) Tom Schreck (117-111 Broner) Personally, I didn't really have a problem with the scoring. But, this isn't about me it's about what the pulse of the boxing fan thinks. A lot of people were outraged by the scorecard in favor of Paulie, and even more were outraged by Schreck's 117-111 scorecard. So, both go up.
Network: Showtime
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

June 29th, 2013:
Fight: Brandon Gonzales-Thomas Oosthuizen
Judges: Clark Sammartino, Glenn Feldman
Network: HBO
Promoter: Lou DiBella

July 5th, 2013:
Fight: Billy Dib-Mike Oliver
Referee: Mike Ortega
Network: ESPN2

July 20th, 2013:
Fight: Dereck Chisora-Malik Scott
Referee: Phil Edwards (Again, I didn't really have a problem with what referee Phil Edwards did. I place all the blame on Scott for not getting up in time. But, there was a lot of outrage, so he gets a mention.)
Network: Boxnation
Promoter: Frank War-ren

July 27th, 2013:
Fight: Jesus Soto-Karass vs Andre Berto
Judges: Hubert Minn, Michael Mitchell (an honorable mention goes to Cathy Leonard. She had the fight in favor of Karass which is correct, but only by a couple of points.)
Network: Showtime
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

August 2nd, 2013:
Fight: Kermit Cintron-Jonathan Batista
Judges: Chris Ritter, Jerry Griffin, David Sutherland
Referee: Gerald Ritter
Network: ESPN2
Promoter: Warrior's Boxing

August 2nd, 2013:
Fight: Javier Fortuna-Luis Franco
Judges: Chris Ritter
Referee: Gary Ritter
Network: ESPN2
Promoter: Warrior's Boxing

 

Moving this to page two for now:

October 21st, 2011:
Fight: Edwin Rodriguez-Will Rosininsky
Judges: Glenn Feldman, Peter Hart, and Clark Sammartino
Promoter: Lou DiBella

October 21st, 2011:
Fight: Jorge Saurez-Larry Smith
Judges: Raul Ortega, Hector Maldonado, Manuel Chapa
Referee: Tony Garcia
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

November 5th, 2011:
Fight: Ricky Burns-Michael Katsidis
Judges: Terry O'Connor, John Stewart, Andre Van Grootenbruel
Promoter: Frank W.

November 5th, 2011:
Fight: Steve Molitor-Sebastian Gauthier
Judges: Nicolas Esnault, and Claude Paquette
Promoter: InterBox

November 11th, 2011:
Fight: Michael Oliveira-Xavier Toliver
Referee: Robert Chapa
Promoter: Gary Shaw

November 12th, 2011:
Fight: Tyson Fury-Neven Pajkic
Referee: Phil Edwards
Promoter: Mick Hennessy

November 13th, 2011:
Fight: Manny Pacquiao-Juan Manuel Marquez
Judges: Glenn Trowbridge, Dave Moretti, Robert Hoyle
Promoter: Top Rank

December 3rd, 2011:
Fight: Robert Helenius-Dereck Chisora
Judges: Giuseppe Quartarone, Manuel Oliver Palomo, Leszek Jankowisk
Referee: Adrio Zannoni
Promoter: Sauerland

February 4th, 2012
Fight: Nonito Donaire-Wilfredo Vazquez Jr.
Judge: Dr. Ruben Garcia
Promoter: Top Rank

February 11th, 2012:
Fight: Juan Carlos Sanchez-Rodrigo Guerrero
Judge: Dr. Ruben Garcia
Promoter: Zanfer Promotions

February 18th, 2012:
Fight: Tavoris Cloud-Gabriel Campillo
Judge: David Robertson and Joel Elizondo
Promoter: Don King

March 11th, 2012:
Fight: Orlando Salido-Juan Manuel Lopez II
Judges: Denny Nelson, Michael Pernick, Cesar Ramos
Promoter: Top Rank

March 23rd, 2012
Fight: Enzo Maccarinelli-Shane McPhilbin
Ref: Ian John-Lewis
Promoter: Frank W. (Just a cluster this fight was. A real disgrace.)

March 23rd, 2012:
Fight: Roberto Garcia-Antwone Smith
Judge: Hector Maldonado
Promoter: Warriors Boxing
+ Ring smaller than what the AIBA rules allow.

March 23rd, 2012:
Fight: Johnny Garcia-Yordenis Ugas
Judges: Gonzalo Valenzuela, Rubin Taylor, and Chris Flores
Promoter: Top Rank

March 24th, 2012:
Fight: James Kirkland-Carlos Molina
Judge: Gale Van Hoy
Ref: Jon Schorle
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

March 24th, 2012:
Fight: Danny Garcia-Erik Morales
Judges: Oren Shellenberger, Mark Green, Samuel Conde Lopez
Promoter: Golden Boy Promotions

April 14th, 2012:
Fight: Mike Alvarado-Mauricio Herrera
Judge: Robert Hoyle
Promoter: Top Rank

April 14th, 2012:
Fight: Brandon Rios-Richard Abril
Judges: Jerry Roth, Glenn Trowbridge
Promoter: Top Rank

May 5, 2012:
Fight: Edmund Gerber-Maurice Harris
Judges: Rainer Schwarz, Josef Temml, Joerg Milke
Promoter: Sauerland

 

3rd page.

 

:good Cool. I'll put it up on the first page.