Top 5 (+) most overrated and underrated fighters in each division , including p4p

Whenever I didn't list 5 and weight divisions that I omitted I might edit in d future and add them .

This content is protected

overrated :

P4P :

Muhammad Ali
Bob Fitzsimmons
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Gene Tunney
Harry Greb
Willie Pep
Walker Smith Jr.

HM : Ezzard Charles , Archie Wright , Carlos Monzon , Roy Jones Jr. , Pernell Whitaker ,

HW :
Muhammad Ali
Joe Louis
Larry Holmes
Gene Tunney
Sonny Liston

HM : Tim Witherspoon , Rocco Marchegiano (how many don't have him in their top 15 ? he was not a heavyweight ) , almost every "heavyweight" champion prior 2 Tyson .

CW :

Max Schmelling
Gene Tunney

HM :

LHW :
Bob Foster
Bernard Hopkins
Billy Conn
John Conteh
Gene Tunney

HM : Matthew Saad Muhammad

SMW :


MW :
Bernard Hopkins
Harry Greb
Les Darcy
Thomas Hearns
Carlos Monzon

LMW :
Thomas Hearns
Terry Norris

HM : Felix Trinidad

WW :
Thomas Hearns
Felix Trinidad
Floyd Mayweather Jr.

HM : Roberto Duran

LWW :
Aaron Pryor
Floyd Mayweather Jr.

LW :
Roberto Duran
Pernell Whitaker
Alexis Arguello
Floyd Mayweather Jr.

FW :
Willie Pep

underrated :

P4P :
Sim Thompkins
Chris Byrd
Orlin Norris

HM : Jose Luis Ramirez , Jorge Fernando Castro

HW :
Nicolay Valuev
Oliver McCall
David Tua
Ross Puritty
Lamon Brewster

HM : Jameel McCline , Henry Akiwande , Hasim Rahman , Oleg Maskaev , Corrie Sanders , Orlin Norris ( not that Norris , Sanders , Rahman , Maskaev should b top 25 but they still get underrated )

CW :
O'neil Bell
James Warring
Guillermo Jones
Alfred Cole
Orlin Norris

HM : Bert Cooper , Nate Miller
LHW :
Doug Jones
Jimmy Ellis
Lou DeValle
Eric Harding
Montell Griffin

HM : Lloyd Marshall

SMW :
Tony Thornton
Merqui Sosa
Steve Little

HM : Steve Collins

MW :
Tony Thornton
Robbi Sims
Sanderline Williams
Steve Collins
Rubin Carter


HM : Jorge Fernando Castro , Tommy West

how many will put them in top 15 ? besides of Sims whom might rank a little lower really .

LMW :
Carmen Basilio
Julian Jackson (could have always made this weight and was vastly superior 2 Terry Norris)


WW :
Aaron Davis
Simon Brown
Jose Luis Lopez
Sim Thompkins

HM : William Kid Parker

LWW :
Frankie Randall
Sammy Angott
Vinny Pazienza
Duilio Loi

LW :
Jose Luis Ramirez
Sammy Angott
Duilio Loi

FW :

Juan LaPorte

HM : Salvador Sanchez

BW :

Pete Santol
Jorge Lujan


HM : Sixto Escobar (?)

 

Where were u when some1 favored Mike McCallum 2 TKO him and another 1 chose him 2 beat him ?
Most here also take Ezzard Charles 4 granted as a better fighter , but it's just like saying that Charles was a better heavy than Louis or 2 say that Rocco was a superior heavy 2 Louis because they beat him .