Who is the higher ATG: Mayweather or DelaHoya?

My proxy vote for Isal/Uliuli:

Oscar De La Hoya by a mile!

:yep

 

I got your back, Lanc, but don't take it seriously: Money is still the GOAT. :deal

 

DLH and not even close. DLH took on just about every p4p number 1 fighter, won some and loss some. Mayweather has fought many titlists, but no where near the opposition to prove how good he is. I would expect DLH to have the same record as Mayweather and look just as great against the same opposition. On the other hand, I could see Mayweather taking on some lumps to his record, and definitely a few scares taking on the same opposition DLH has.

 

FAWLS! Money beat 2 top 5 p4p fiters in his lassed 3 fights, *******! atsch:rofl PLUS hatton dln n corrales n castiyo all p4p top 10 when they fite. check ur fax *****!

 

Oscar, but Void wins as the best woman beater!

 

I would go with Floyd based on the fact that he beat an A fighter in their prime. Oscar doesn't have that on his resume. One thing that alot of people say about Oscar is that he didn't win alot of his biggest fights. It is what it is.

 

Hahahaha, you should also check your facts. If you've followed my post history I've been critical of both Pac and May, but I think May takes a fight between the two.

Top 10 p4p isn't the same as taking on the p4p kings in their respective divisions and in their primes.

Answer this: If DLH took on Mayweather's opposition do you think he would have lost any of those fights?

 

lissen lemme holla at u dlh was gr8 but had bad spanima n hatton and castiyo wudda broke him down n dlh wudnt had size disadvantage with corrales or ortiz and it wudda been close!

 

Oscar for sure.

 

Oscar

 

Floyd, he's won his big fights.
I love Oscar, but the Floyd fight was his chance to leap into one of the top three of his era.

 

I hate Floyd's personality but when it comes to boxing he's definitely higher ATG than Oscar to me. Why? Mostly because in my opinion Oscar lost fights that he needed to have won to be higher ranked than PBF. Also with Floyd there is a case of his unique style, nobody fights like him.FLoyd seems to be unbeatable right now, there are maximum 2 fighter who CAN (and that's not sure even) beat him. Others are out of his league. You couldn't say that about Oscar even when he was still unbeaten. there were much more guys there to give him an even fight

 

You consider Vargas an A fighter? Why?