1. Remember when Marquez lost to Floyd after coming off a good win. JMM moved up in weight got outclassed and was dropped of the top 5 P4P list even though he was coming off a long winning streak. Pac looked decent against old man Mosley, and got schooled by JMM so isn't it fair to take him off the list? O I forgot Marquez, and fair dont go together. 2. If Pac has had to fights in a row where cramps are a problem even after having good camps, he is no longer P4P worthy because it means he will never get back to the old (cramp free) Manny. New list 1.Martinez 2.Floyd 3.Marquez 4. Ward or Froch (depending on fight) 5. Wlad Klit
Void is Void. SOB refused to allow Bute to fight in his personal tournament, everyone has to travel except SOB! Void lost to Castillo and Oscar. Pac stopped Oscar and Cotto! Pac fought Margarito Void refused. Void still refuses to fight Pac and for good reason!
What an overreaction. Pac was the undisputed P4P king until recently and one tough outing against his old nemesis changes all that? No way.
I think Manny is top 5 P4P. I don't believe he is number 1 though. He got out boxed by a lightweight. He was suppose to dominate Marquez but was out boxed. Manny was suppose to show that he was on a different level and failed horribly.
I had him # 1 prior to last night. After the fight, I've dropped him behind Floyd. You could also make the case that Martinez may have replaced Pac as #2, with Pac dropping to #3.
Floyd Manny Marquez/Martinez Donaire/Wlad Even had Marquez taken the official win, Manny would not come down from #2 p4p. At least not lower than Marquez. Manny, p4p, is still a bigger threat all around considering all aspects of both fighters.
I think this is the first time in boxing history where muscle cramps were supposedly to blame for 2 back to back poor performances.
