Would JMM have beaten the 140 lb and up guys Manny beat

In the forms that they were on the night of their fights with Pacquiao would JMM have beat

Oscar, Hatton, Cotto, Clottey, Mosley, Margo

I saw some one going on how JMM did not accomplish what Manny has an what not weight jumping wise.

So it got me thinking would Marquez win these fights

 

No, he doesn't have the physical talent to do it. Bigger guys can more easily walk down a smallish counterpuncher. In other words he'd simply get overwhelmed by the size differential.

 

He'd beat Hatton badly, at 140lbs.

 

hatton yes cotto maybe. not sure but in pac vs marquez 3 he looked like a solid welter

 

Plaster-less Cheato probably wouldn't beat Marquez, come to think about it.

 

Cotto would be his toughest challenge.

I'd love to see that fight.

 

Cotto, Clottey, and Margarito fighting at 165 pounds would be very difficult. I'd favor the Marquez who should've beaten Pacquiao last month over De La Hoya, Mosley, and Hatton.

 

Margarito would would through jmm punches and then marg will put on the pressure and give jmm a beating of his life.

 

Cotto, Clottey, Margarito, and Mosley all stop Juan.

Hatton's gets UD'd. Or maybe takes Juan down with body punching.

 

JMM stops them all, then?

 

Hatton would win. If katsidis troubled jmm like that I am pretty sure hatton would do the same, but x3.

 

I think he wouldnt have beaten any of the guys, maybe hatton./

 

I think he could've beaten Hatton. The other guys are very strong welters and up. Cotto would've been good but, he hits too hard a takes over when he has the strength advantage. Margarito, Oscar would've clobbered him. Better fighter but, not big enough...

 

:deal