My Top 60 p4p- tell me what you'd change

No Kell Brook.

 

Cotto above Gamboa? lol.

 

why is Pacquiao above Marquez?

 

Not a perfect list but i good one.

For the people who say the list is pure bull**** , take the time to do one before judging!

 

If that rdiculous lst was the truth then there would be no way Ward was a top 10 fighter - simply because he would only have been a single person in top 60!! How can such a person be top 10 p4p?

However, in reality SMW is arguably the deepest division in boxing atm and Kessler (who beat Froch) is top 15. Froch is about 15. Bute hasn't really beaten anyone, but I still think a 15-20 ranking is fair. Dirrell I would rank around 35-40 atm.

At least.

And that would make it possible to argue that Ward is top 5.

 

thought it was a good list, obviously when there are 60 fighters people are going to disagree about where they should be placed but there's nothing that stands out as wrong to me. only thing i would say is that i dont think arce should be ahead of guys like khan, i dont think he has much left in the tank. also maybe nishioka is a bit high? other than that i pretty much agree with everything :good

 

How is Bute ahead of Hopkins and what is Pascal doing at 50?

 

yall mustve forgot RJJ still pound for pound the baddest your know what to lace up a pair of gloves

 

Klit's too high. Neither can can even gain dominance in their own division, much less claim pound for pound top ten ranking.

Dawson should be ahead of Hopkins. We saw what happens when those two get in the ring. Hopkins cries until someone stops the fight.

Not a bad overall list though.

Good job.

Keith

 

:good

 

Put Khan on #60 he needs to work up the ladder as it's obvious he hasn't earned your respect. So a SD win over Khan and Peterson sonic boom's to the top lol. Good 4 Peterson we want to see him thrive against other top 10 contenders.

 

donaire knocks fighters out on a regular basis, even other top fighters, he should be ranked ahead of martinez

 

Too high:
Cotto
Gamboa
Froch
Peterson
Cloud *
Khan *
Adamek
Ortiz
Erdei
Tarver *
Rigondeaux *

Too low:
Dawson
Moreno *
Gonzalez
Pascal
Burns
Juanma *
Kessler *

Asterisks being the big disagreements. Good job posting this though.

Where are Takashi Uchiyama and Hernan Marquez? They certainly make the cut. Also: Adrian Hernandez and Rungvisai.

 

Fair play doing this list overall i think it's fairly good. I'm not going to be pedantic and start saying so and so should be here etc...
Don't see any one else putting in this much effort!!! and i wont ha