Is It Reasonable to Have JMM Ranked Ahead of Pacquiao P4P?

:!:
The Ring has been a joke for years
:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl

 

ATG Pac ranks ahead of him even with the robbery.
But currently p4p i have JMM at 2 and Pac at 3 as i do not acknowledge official results when its so blatently obvious that it was a robbery.
Same as i do not rate Helenius over Chisora or Williams over Lara.

Some decisions are so disgraceful you can not use the official result.

 

1. Mayweather
2. JMM
3. Pacquiao

 

No it's not.

Next thread.

 

If you're one of those people who keeps boxing records for fighters that are entirely separate from the official record, then I suppose it makes sense that you would also have your own P4P list based on that record.

Just don't run around here acting like Floyd being 41-1 or Pac being 52-6-1 is some sort of universal fact. The official record is more important than your record, so that's what I go by.

 

Two close fights and one really close fight or even a loss don't erase entire careers, or you would be ranking Gene Fulmer and Joey Maxim or even Carmen Basilio (the most deserving) over Sugar Ray Robinson, absurd in light of their entire careers.

With a different ref, Pac almost blew JMM out IN ONE ROUND. Has Jmm even come close to doing that or even had Pac off his feet? So even though their fights are always close, Pac deserves the edge for sure, because JMM should count himself lucky not to have a 1 round KO loss on his record.

 

Which means that Sven Ottke is the p4p GOAT at SMW.

 

See, I don't really get that ranking, and a lot of people seem to abide by it by default. Beating the #1 should get you a higher place than having beaten the man who beat the #1.

 

No
1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Marquez

That's how it should be.

 

SO looking at the 154 pound division.

Who would you guys rank higher?
PW or Lara?

 

I bet you wish that Pac had gotten that 1st round KO uh? Then you wouldnt have as many nightmares. JMM is too good to be stopped.

 

sigh...

Pac beat Marquez, barely, twice...

Pac above Marquez, always and forever...