Still have pac top results wise, would put Maywether ahead but can't justify a win over b-level Ortiz in nearly two years as P4P champ. Marquez 2, May 3 and then Martinez and Doniare 4 and 5. On my opinion on where they are in their careers and who would win if they could all fight each other it would be 1. May 2. JMM 3. Pac. 4. martinez 5. Donire. A good win early 2012 for Mayweather would be enough to put him top imo - beating Pac, JMM, khan, Martinez, Cotto/Marg winner would certainly see him elevated back to the top
"The eye test" means so much to me personally...Floyd IS the P4P#1 for me, and has been for some time. Pac just LOOKS to have too many weaknesses to contest Floyd.
I think floyd is unbeatable around his weight class but there's other's i'd say the same for: donaire, martinez, gamboa, wlad.
:scaredas: So JMM beats Manny yet he is below Nonito and Martinez. At least have him at 3...come on. I feel the nr1 spot is vacant. Floyd would be the logical answer but he is so damn inactive.
I see many of you have FMJ as number 1 now. Was beating Ortiz with a cheap but legal shot a better accomplishment than Pac going to war and having a questionable victory over the living legend JMM? :huh
I wonder if anyone has changed their opinion now that the dust has settled recently? Floyd has quite a massive lead at the time of this post.
After the pathetic performance by Pac against the #5 JMM and the gift decision over that #5 JMM- I got Floyd at my one spot Pac at my 2 spot Sergio at my 3 spot Donaire at my 4 spot JMM at my 5 spot