Rank these fighters in terms of P4P and legacy?

u mad bro?

 

We'll never know who would or wouldn't. All I know is there's noone i'd expect to :good

 

manbearpig does not have swagger.

 

Jones beat both Toney and Hopkins, so it' ridiculous to have either over them especially since Jones went on to win so many titles.

1. Jones
2. Holyfield
3 Hopkins


4. Toney



Keith

 

Yes, very much so. :verysad

True, we never know, we just can go by indications. Not all want to see them though.

Guess you rank Kirkland Laing over Roberto Duran too.

 

Holyfield (brawling still)
Jones (battered a lot, then got battered a lot)
Bhop (bawled and brawled in equal measure)
Toney (blubbered out)

not sure who Keith is but by default hes number 5 -

Keith (battyboy style)

 

really? I love you, but I have to post this on Manbearpig's behalf

This content is protected

sorry bro, I love you, but I had to do it.

 

He never used that rationale though, he said that Jones beat both Toney and Hopkins AND went on to do so well in addition to that.

No need for trolling and or twisting his words man.

 

Oh, he did since he wrote that "it' ridiculous to have either over them" since "Jones beat both Toney and Hopkins" which exactly is that logic. Yes, he mentioned that Jones did well too. Nevertheless he stated that you can´t rank Hopkins and Toney over Jones because he beat them. So, I was neither trolling nor twisting words. q.e.d.

 

are you really doing this? His sentence carried on after 'you have to rank Jones over Toney and Hopkins because he beat them both. That wasn 't the end of the sentence.

You really gunna clutch at them straws bro?

 

Don´t be so elitist and supress my opinion. :bart

 

it's not an opinion, it's you twisting the words of a poster. I already told you earlier in this thread that your opinion AND Manbearpigs opinion are both fine.

Twisting peoples words to read what you want to read is all I have an issue with, apart from that you're doing fine.

 

Jones
Hopkins
Holyfield




Toney



Hopkins and Holyfield very close but the steroid thing sticks in my throat so just about swings it for bernard

 

Evander Holyfield
Bernard Hopkins
Roy Jones Jr.
James Toney

fighting the best has its rewards.

 

exactly like I had it. Jones to me gets lower here because of his lack of looking for the best competition.