If old Vitali fights and beats Haye impressively...

...is he greater than his brother Wlad?

Vitali looks just as dominant with a style that people like. He doesn't fight scared of getting punched. He has been on the top (#1 or #2) of the division since 2003. My question is: if he beats Haye in a impressive fashion, is he greater than Wlad?

 

I always felt h2h prime vitali> prime volodja

 

I think Vitali is greater than Wlad, not at the moment because Vitali is shot but prime 4 prime, Vitali was the better Klitschko.

 

The same David Haye that is retired?

 

In an All Time Great list, would you rank Vitali above Wladimir? :think

Wlad has beat better opponents (Haye, Byrd, Chagaev) and has been more dominant (2006-2012).

However, Vitali has good arguments because he has beat many contenders while being past his prime. And has been dominant against all his opponents since the start of his career.

 

Sure but have any of them that great an opponent and Wlad has also been stopped more convincingly than Vitali ever was too. On a purely technical boxing level, you can easily make the argument that Wlad is the better "boxer", when you count intangibles like heart and toughness ... for me Vitali is the more complete fighter.

 

Then Vitali will have fought the best option available for him at the moment.

 

Wlad is the better Klitschko. He fought his way back to the top. He is the much better boxer and never quit in a fight.

 

I always felt Vitali is the better Klitschko. But imo he should tell haye to face 1 top heavyweight contender before facing vitali too see if haye is still a threat cause if vitali beats a retired 1 year layoff haye, there will be soo many excuses as to why vitali beat haye.

 

Haters are going to say that he beat old, fat, semi-retired Haye

 

Haye does nothing for Vitali, Just another notch on his belt. Wlad already beat the best version of Haye. Wlad;s resume is twice as good as Vitali's. He is a better boxer and has more power, is more athletic.

 

styles make fights. vitali is slower so his fight with haye will be more action packed than with his brother. he may wind up looking better than his brother

 

thats why it be better if vitali tells haye to fight atleast 1 top heavyweight contender before facing vitali.

 

Vitali will knock Haye out, in a mismatch!!!

 

Vitali is already greater than Wlad. Wlad fights like a chicken. Vitali will fight haye not jab and grab like Wlad did. Wlad was scared to get hit by Haye.