agreed, JWH is a better fit for any team than SBW, he's got that mongrel & is a winner, SBW is more of an individual
SBW should play in the centres if he comes back or the second row... the lock position wont fit him as well the second time around and he needs more ball up the middle to have a similar impact
They need to keep JWH because of the work he does in defence but if it comes down to the crunch SBW shits on him from a great height in attack.
im going to go out on a limb and say your going to get a shock... i reckon he wont be the guy we all remember even when he hits his peak again... the time in rugby, the injuries etc wont go unnoticed
It would be going out on a small limb too, SBW is in career best form right now. He is playing out of his skin in this years Super 15. He will be coming back better than ever.
Im going to go out of a limb and say i would take SBW in my team over any player besides Billy slater in the nrl.. Sbw is 27 but would probably feel about 23 in the body department..He barely had to make a tackle or barely got tackled in union..Definately preserved his body.. He will tear the nrl apart when he comes back..
surgery bill williams wont last 12 weeks back in the nrl without another long stint on the injured list. biggest waste of money possibly ever in the nrl
As a Parramatta fan, I can utterly prove that false. PS Hayne in form is 1 of 3 of the best players in the NRL atm. The other two are Inglis and Slater.
:yep what was i thinking!! i feel your pain bro.. i feel your pain.. id actually take gallen over inglis but im sure plenty would disagree
Imo, and this is gunna sound funny to most, but Sutton has been more consistent than GI this year. GI has had one super game, but in the other two games, he was simply starved of good ball. No fault of his own mind you, and he was still solid defensively, but he just didnt get the opportunities he had last Sunday. Sutton along with Burgess was our best in the CS, was also very good in round 1, and was probably 2nd best on the fild last Sunday against the pink shirts. I really like the way Sutton has been going this year. Has a bit more agro in his defence, never seems to give up as much as he used to, and it was good to see him start pushing the Penny player when he got tackled last. In past years, he would have simply just looked at the ref waiting for a penalty. He is a big man, and it's about time he started to throw his weight around. That aside, Issac Luke would be the one player I'd hate to get injured at Souths, followed by GI, and Burgess. Most of our attacking raids relies on Luke's strong bustling darts through the middle. Peats is a solid player, but is no replacement for Luke.