Vitali and Wlad's best win?

For me, Vitaly's losing effort against Lewis is his best performance.

Wlad will always be the 1st Byrd thrashing.

 

Vitali: Sanders, Johnson and Peter

Wladimir: Chagaev, Byrd and Peter

 

Vitali - Peter (dominated the current champ after a lay off)

Wlad - Byrd

 

I still think that Sanders was a better win.. But they're probably close..

 

Wlad: 1: Byrd 2: Chagaev 3: Peter.
.
Vitali: 1: Peter 2: Sanders 3: Williams.

 

Wladimir : 1- Byrd 2- Haye 3-Peter
Vitali : 1-Sanders 2-Peter there isnt number 3 hide.williams,adamek,chisora ??

 

For Wladimir: Byrd, Haye, Chagaev

For Vitali: Sanders, Arreola, Adamek

 

Wladimir Klitschko

- IBF/WBO/WBA/IBO/RING Unified Heavyweight Champion of the world

- All Time Great and Hall Of Famer

- Olympic Gold Medalist

- Ring Magazine Top 5 P4P Fighter

- 57 wins, 50 knockouts

- Statistically 2nd most dominant fighter of all time

- longest title reign without getting knocked down

- has made 17 title defences

Has defeated 11 world champions: Chris Byrd x 2, Sam Peter x 2, David Haye, Ruslan Chagaev, Sultan Ibragimov, Lamon Brewster, Hasim Rahman, Frans Botha, Jean Marc Mormeck, Ray Mercer

Has defeated tons of top contenders: Eddie Chambers, Tony Thompson, Jameel McCline, Calvin Brock, Monte Barrett, Axel Schulz, Ray Austin, DaVarryl Williamson, Derrick Jefferson, Charles Shufford, Eliseo Castillo, Phil Jackson, etc.


Vitali Klitschko

- WBC Heavyweight Champion of the world

- All Time Great and Hall Of Famer

- Has never truly lost

- There is no blueprint to beat him

- He is unbeatable

- Statistically most dominant fighter of all time

- He has dominated every opponent he has ever faced

- 46 have tried and 46 have been dominated

- Has never been behind on the scorecards at the end of a fight

- Has never been knocked down

- Greatest Heavyweight Champ KO% of all time

- Only man ever to be world heavyweight champ in boxing and kickboxing

- has made 12 title defences

- Ring Magazine Top 10 P4P Fighter

- Vitali is 40 and is still dominating

It's a shame that the 4 year layoff robbed him of a stronger resume. He was WBC and RING undisputed HW Champ when he retired in 2004. We never got to see his true prime. If Vitali had stayed healthy, he would've dominated the HW division from 2005-2008 and his resume would've been on par with Wladimir's great resume.

Best wins: Corrie Sanders, Lennox Lewis, Sam Peter, Tomasz Adamek, Herbie Hide, Chris Arreola, Odlanier Solis, Juan Carlos Gomez, Shannon Briggs, Larry Donald, Kirk Johnson, Dereck Chisora, Danny Williams, Kevin Johnson, Vaughn Bean, Albert Sosnowski, Timo Hoffman, Orlin Norris, Ross Purrity, etc.

 

Wladimir-


Top level wins - Ibragimov, Haye, Byrd, R. Chagaev, E. Chambers

Decent wins - R. Mercer, C. Brock, L. Brewster, T. Thompson, S. Peter twice, F. Botha



Vitali top level wins - C. Sanders (just)

Decent wins - Arreola, Solis, S. Peter, Chisora, Williams, K. Johnson, JC Gomez, L. Donald, H. Hide, S. Briggs



Wladimir has far better top tier wins, Vitali as a string of decent wins.


In the greatness aspect...Vitali is better head to head but Wlad resume is far better.


Both around 10-25 ATG depending on individuals accounts of greatness.

 

Solis was outboxing Vitali before injury does that mean we count that one as Vitali losing?


Lennox Lewis beat Vitali enough said.

 

Good post :good.. But sometimes i am able to squeeze Wlad inside the top 10 using my excellent troll skills