H2H kings of the traditional 8 divisions?

HW: Lewis
LHW: Jones
MW: Monzon
WW: Leonard
LW: Duran
FW: Saddler
BW: ??
FLW: ??

 

****, this is hard!

HW - Louis
LHW - Ezzard Charles
MW - Fitzsimmons
WW - Robinson (was slightly tempted to say Tommy Hearns tho)
LW - Duran
FW - Pep
BW - Zarate
Fly - Jimmy Wilde

As you can tell, I have mainly selected guys with freakish power for their weight. Charles I feel could outbox any LHW in history, while Pep would beat most Feathers. Duran, while not a concussive puncher, could bang, and he had great boxing skills to back them up (do any other LWs beat Leonard?)

Of course I'm taking a chance with Middleweight here (was going to say Hagler), but how many other MWs in history could cleanly KO THE Heavyweight champion? Same with Wilde (lack of footage, not a great list of opposition etc), but he has the power to level most in the division.

 

At BW you can choose between Jofre and Al Brown IMHO......Jofre had the overall package, power, defense, great offensive skills, very versatile.....Al Brown had the size combined with the jab, power, counter-punching skills and was very good defensively....was kind of a BW Thomas Hearns as someone else said here in Classic before.....

FLW is really hard, I made a topic recently, and people can´t pick one with confidence apparently......

MW I would pick Monzon...but a case can be made for Hagler I think.....

 

HW Joe Frazier (I feel comfortable against everyone outside of Foreman/Liston)
LHW- Gene Tunney
MW Charley Burley
WW SRR
LW Armstrong (Dark horse Bob Montgomery)
FW Saddler
BW Joltin' Jeff Chandler
Fly Midget Wolgast

 

HW : basically :-( but if forced 2 pick 1 it's SNV
CW : D Real Deal , possibly .
LHW : :-( but in more detail : Spinks , Moorer , Doug Jones , Langford , Charles and more may have a claim 2 it .
SMW : :-( Langford , Charles and more
MW : :-( Langford , Hagler , Monzon , Charles and more
LMW : :-( McCallum (despite i'd slightly favor Hearns 2 decision him) , WSJ , Burley and others , probably Langford again as 1 of d others
WW : WSJ probably , possibly Burley or some1 else
LWW : :-( Angott , Ross or some1 else
LW : Armstrong , Joyce , Angott , Chavez , Ramirez , Canzoneri , McLarnin , Ross
___________ or possibly even some1 else
SFW : :-( Pacquiao / Armstrong but maybe some1 else ? Brian Mitchell maybe ?
FW : Sanchez
SBW : :-( Gomez ?
BW : :-( Jofre ?
superfly :
fly :
lightfly :
minimum : :-( Lopez ????

overall , this is y h2h lists r 4 , it's better than just picking a random #1 outof d A .

 

HW: Lewis
LHW: Jones
MW: Monzon
WW: Robinson (Would honestly pick Hearns if its over 12 rounds)
LW: Leonard
FW: Pep
BW: Jofre
FLW: Wilde

 

:happy

 

Me too. :good

 

I've always been a supporter of Roy in general , but i don't think he's the best head-to-head at 175.He didn't hit nearly as hard as he did at middle and there's too many who wouldn't be flustered or totally outclassed by speed and would be the better more domineering physical fighters over 15.especially after a few hard-fought rounds and getting all up in his grill yo.

That's not Jones thing.As a smaller built power puncher who fought like a pure boxer and takes as little risks as possible with letting his hands go he really needs to be able to thoroughly deter with speed\ power.I don't see that as possible against some of the 175 beasts, hell he couldn't even discourage Mike McCallum and had to really open up on overmatched triers like Clinton Woods. hall and Griffin at this weight.

He's still very formidable, but too cautious and safety-first to outwork the likes of Spinks, Moore, Charles etc and he would need to if he can't get their respect.lets not kid ourselves he has anything other than a slim outside bet of knocking any of these guys out.I think he's more a fighter who could steal wins over anyone at the weight over 10 rounds, even against the very highest rated.Especially if they come in during a tough schedule and not at 100%.Peak vs Peak over 15...not so much.

 

Bantam: Jofre
Fly: Perez

 

Fly is hard between Perez, Lynch and Canto IMO.

 

Canto has just cried a little inside

 

Harada?