H2H kings of the traditional 8 divisions?

HW - Ali
LHW - Spinks
MW - SRR
WW - SRR
LW - Duran
FW - Armstrong
BW - Zarate

 

Quite frankly, no.

I was never impressed with his punching power even in his earlier "Little Tyson" days.

His punches never looked crisp to me.

It was more a combination of Guzman's speed, talent and overmatched opponents that earned him reputation as a puncher, in my opinion.

By the way i even remember Ring magazine listed Guzman's right hand as the hardest punch in super bantamweight division

The only time Guzman truly demonstrated good punching power was against ancient-coming out of 3 year layoff Agapito Sanchez.

And moving up in weight didn't help matters either.

 

I considered this earlier but thought I'd be blasted by the majority of people posting in this thread:think

 

Literally if someone doesn't agree with your opinion you have a very stubborn approach to responding. What more could donaire have done after winning every round with ease? It takes two to tango sir :hey

 

Guzman was always a style over substance slopfest, even though he did have a good amount of raw talent earlier in his career.He never developed it.

Nowhere near one of the most formidable at any weight.

 

Top 3 in each division

Heavyweight: Muhammad Ali, George Foreman, Joe Frazier

Lightheavy: Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore, Billy Conn

Middleweight: Ray Robinson, Marvin Hagler, Freddie Steele

Welterweight: Ray Robinson, Ray Leonard, Kid Gavilan

Lightweight: Pernell Whitaker, Roberto Duran, Ike Williams

Featherweight: Henry Armstrong, Salvador Sanchez, Sandy Saddler

Bantamweight: Eder Jofre, Fighting Harada, Ruben Olivares,

Flyweight: Benny Lynch, Pascual Perez, Miguel Canto

 

Not on the night he wasn't

Who are you? 'Unbeatable'? Obviously I'm the extremist

 

I agree with everyone on John Thomas list except at MW I would put Monzon. Also if we're going to give guys a 24 hour weigh in I nominate Panama Al Brown for flyweight, as he could easily made 112 then rehydrated to featherweight.

 

Fair assessment, he certainly did wing his shots

He would have beat a few top FWs in history Pacquaio and Barrera included

 

Not much love for Jofre in here.

 

No but then again few in history would be, most gain a few pounds after, these days they gain more and maybe cheat a bit with diuretics and water manipulation if they're smart

 

I had him, but I'm a 'hater' so what do I know? The real answer is Rodel Mayol, a bantam in most other era's I imagine and much more modern than the Brazilian.

 

Nonito actively bragged about coming in over 130lbs against Narvaez. That's the difference.

Montiel was heavier than him. But if they were feathers weighing in on the day, the win would be just as prestigious.

 

in 3-4 years,Mikey is a top 5 p4p fighter :bbb