In this month's issue of the ring, thought it worth posting. The ring listed the top 5 hw's decade by decade and then ranked the decade on overall quality of the field. 1890's - Grade B. Jeffries Fitzsimmons Corbett Maher Sharkey 1900's - B+ Johnson Jeffries Langfrod Jeannette McVea 1910's - B Dempsey Johnson Langford Wills Jeannette 1920's - C+ Dempsey Wills Tunney Sharkey Godfrey 1930's - C- Louis Schmelling Baer Braddock Sharkey 1940's - B- Louis Charles Walcott Bivins Ray 1950's - B Marciano Liston (!) Charles Walcott Patterson 1960's - B+ Ali Frazier Liston Patterson Ellis (!) 1970's - A+ Ali Foreman Frazier Holmes Norton 1980's - B- Tyson Holmes Witherspoon Holyfield Spinks 1990's - A- Holyfield Lewis Bowe Tyson Ibeabuchi (!) 2000's - C Lewis Wladimir Vitali Byrd Chagaev 2010's - D+ Wladimir Vitali Povetkin Haye Adamek Thoughts? I put exclamation marks next to the picks I thought were the worst 3.
Nothing wrong with Jimmy Ellis making #5 of the 1960s. I think the relative overall grades for each decade are all very debatable.
You're gonna get a lot of this until you have your list ironed out but - Peter Jackson is a lock for the 1890's. Probably bumps the grade, too.
can't be arsed checking boxrec but wasn't the machen ko1 in 60? and the patterson ko? if either aren't then I'll rescind my criticism on that. was ellis any better than terrell though?
*Ingo ko'd Machen in '58 and Patterson in '59. I don't know their criteria. If h2h, Liston makes sense in the '50's. If on accomplishments in the decade, he does not and it should have gone to Johansson. I would have gone with Ingo and listed Liston only in the '60's. My criterium would have been if this man were stretched in his first fight of the next decade, and then vanished from top-level boxing, would he be viewed as a top man. Dempsey in the teens would be. Liston in the fifties would not.
Interesting list. While I don't necessarily agree with the order some of the top 5 picks, I agree with the ratings of each decade. If you were to put this in the general forum they Klitschko trolls would send you virtual anthrax.