Pacquiao vs Hatton 140 who wins?

It was a rhetorical question

There is whiff of hypocrisy around. Your rationale is Pac is quicker and more intelligent, therefore he'd be able to beat Hatton to the punch. Fair enough. So then why can Joe Calzaghe not do this, when he is in a weight division equally absurd for his frame?

Don't give me any **** about punching power either, Pac's has diminshed notably as he scaled the weights

 

I'm glad you understand and respect my assessment...Wheres Joe fit in here?? I understand your point but who's he fighting??

 

Do you not remember our little thread in which we discussed Joe Calzaghe vs. a number of HW's excluding Wlad? Chagaev, Ibragimov maybe?

Baring in mind Hatton is p4p much higher than the aforementioned fighters, and both Calzaghe/Pacquiao would be defying logic in those weight divisions I struggle to see how Pac wins, yet Calzaghe can't even compete

 

Nope... Pacdbest the one & only Pacdbest. I don't use different names. You can see me at Pacland too.

The guy has his own mind & looks like a Brave guy who thinks like me & see things like me. He's thinking right.

Nobody thinks Nonito can beat Darchinyan, but I saw it.

 

Well sorry to burst your bubble but hatton will ko him in 10.

 

you could add danny williams into that.

 

It's a matter of 10lbs vs 33lbs... the comparison you're trying to get at is a horrible one mate the differences are:
other than 10lbs Hatton and Pac are the exact same height
Pac has a 2" reach advantage

For Joe to reach HW you can't begin to fathom the weightlifting needed to produce that much weight....dare we speculate on how much this slows Joe down??.......So I see your point...I hope you understand mine...I hope you can understand why:good

 

Id pick Pac to beat Juan Diaz 9/10 but Hatton is not only bigger but a stylistic nightmare for Pac. Unless Pac carries his KO power to 140, he will get bullied all over the ring and ko via bodyshot.

 

yeah well if it was the tyson that destroyed bruno in 85 he would have beat them both in the same night.

 

lol. Well to his credit McBride beat a shot Tyson therefore it wasnt a great win. PacD had a great prediction however, not for the fact that he predicted who would win but he predicted the punch too. My jaw dropped when I watched the fight and looked at how accurate he analysed the fight. He has very strong bias towards Pac but he can analyse fights unlike some who are very rational but only really just follow what the general concensus thinks...

 

Yes, its 10lbs from where Pac is at now, but this is a huge amount for a man that has filled out at the lower weights. It's not like De La Hoya, who was still developing physically, this is Pac's actual frame. His punching power and strength has already diminished at super feather. So he is completely outgunned physically, just as Joe would be

As for height and reach, I think you'd be suprised compared to a guy like Chagaev. Reach would be very similar, and a couple inches in height, Joe loves the taller guys

I take your point about putting the weight on and retaining speed, but then Joe would come in right on the limit. Considering he walks around at 200, it really isn't as dramatic as you make out

Also, Joe is more likely to outbox a bigger guy than Pacquiao. How many Pac fights do you see and say "wow, he completely outboxed that guy". Outfought maybe

The comparison is apt. Thinking about it, I don't truely believe Joe would beat a HW. He would compete for a while. It's your logic that disturbs me, since you confidently predict Pac to beat Hatton

 

:good

 

Id pick Calzaghe to beat plenty of HW's if he went up properly, Mackie Shillstone baby! He wouldnt beat Wlad but he would probably outbox Peter, Chagaev, Valuev, Sultan etc.

 

again hatton kicks his ass...

 

common dumb ass. stop using emoticons to save your ass
all you do is make fun of someone where in fact you got no guts in making an accurate prediction. :roll: just give credit where credit is due. he predicted it right with pin point accuracy. he used his brain. you used your emoticons .
i think you **** yourself cuase you are a ****** going by the minute
:rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl