Quarter finals Roy Jones vs Gerald McClellan Chris Eubank vs Lucian Bute Joe Calzaghe vs James Toney Andre Ward vs Nigel Benn Semi Finals Winner fight 1 vs Winner fight 2 Winner fight 3 vs Winner fight 4 Finals Winner semi final 1 vs Winner semi final 2 3rd Place fight Loser semi final 1 vs Loser semi final 2 All guys at their prime. Bonus match up Carl Froch vs Sven Ottke
Roy Jones vs Gerald McClellan - This would be amazing probaly jones but wouldnt want to call Chris Eubank vs Lucian Bute - Eubank tko 10th Joe Calzaghe vs James Toney - Calz UD Andre Ward vs Nigel Benn - Andre Ward UD
Im assuming there best nights and in a single year this takes place so considered how tough the fights would have been. Q-finals Roy Jones WUD12 G. McCellan C. Eubank WUD12 L. Bute J. Toney WSD12 J. Calazghe A. Ward WUD12 N. Benn Semi-Finals R. Jones WUD12 C. Eubank J. Toney WUD12 A. Ward Final R. Jones WUD12 J. Toney C. Eubank WSD12 A. Ward 3rd place match
that may be controversial for alot of boxing fans, but i feel that stylistically, Calzaghe would've gave even a PRIME Toney fits
same suchg a busy work rate and unstoppable stamina i think toney would be waiting to long for calz to slow down n just get over whelmed. controversial but i take calzaghe over toney. also in his prime before his hands were fukd calzaghe had a good punch
Yeah I tried to make them all 50/50 Eubank would probably have the easiest nights work against Bute, no offence to Lucian I just think he is a step behind a prime Eubank.
Eubank would Knock Bute out cold. Jones get's caught against G-Man. Toney would have to be on his A+ Game to beat Joe. Benn stops Ward.
Quarter finals Roy Jones vs Gerald McClellan -- McClellan KOs Jones Chris Eubank vs Lucian Bute -- Eubank KOs Bute Joe Calzaghe vs James Toney -- Calzaghe widely outpoints Toney Andre Ward vs Nigel Benn -- Benn KOs Ward Semi Finals Winner fight 1 vs Winner fight 2 -- McClellan vs Eubank -- Tough distance fight where both get hurt. I pick Eubank though, he has the SMW resume thats proven Winner fight 3 vs Winner fight 4 -- Calzaghe vs Benn -- Tough brawl, but Calzaghe out toughs Benn and wears Benn down for a late stoppage Finals Winner semi final 1 vs Winner semi final 2 -- Eubank vs Calzaghe, Goes similar to how their original fight went. Calzaghe outworks Eubank for a tough but clear UD 3rd Place fight Loser semi final 1 vs Loser semi final 2 -- McClellan vs Benn. Sadly this fight when it happend had a terrible outcome with McClellans injuries. Its a tough battle again, but I would favour Benn to survive some rocky moments to win a tight dec All guys at their prime. Bonus match up Carl Froch vs Sven Ottke -- Ottke closely outpoints Froch. People underate Ottke who was boring to watch but very difficult to beat. People overate Froch who I like alot, because he is known in America. Ottke fought in a tougher different era. I highly rate Bute and Ward but I think this era of SMWs is weak and if you remove those two there isnt much else
Jones Jr. KO 7 McClellan Bute UD Eubank Toney SD Calzaghe Benn KO 9 Ward Bute KO 7 Jones Jr. Toney UD Benn Toney SD Bute
I have it this way: Jones Jr. KO 10 McClellan Bute UD Eubank Toney SD Calzaghe Ward UD Benn Jones Jr. UD Bute Toney SD Ward Jones Jr. UD Toney