Follow the usual criteria Jab Left Hook/Right Hook Cross Body Attack Upper Body Head Movement Positioning/Using Angles Defense Ring Generalship Countering Stamina Power Chin
Jab - Whitaker Left Hook/Right Hook - Jones Cross - Whitaker Body Attack - Whitaker Upper Body Head Movement - Whitaker Positioning/Using Angles - Whitaker Defense - Whitaker Ring Generalship - Damn...uh, Jones. Countering - Jones Stamina - Even Power - Jones Chin - Whitaker Very close on a lot of those aspects though.
Jab-Whitaker A++++++ jab Roy's was solid when he used it, but it was never that good. Hook-Roy easily. Faster and stronger. Cross- Roy. Faster and stronger. Could throw it upstairs and to the body. Upper Body movement- Whitaker. Roy used his feet more than his upper body to avoid shots. Still close though. Angles Roy. Could punch from anywhere and was always dangerous. Ring Generalship- Tie. Two of the best at it. Countering- Roy's timing is jsut too good. No punch was safe when you threw it. Power-Jones Chin- Tie
Jab - Whitaker Left Hook/Right Hook - RJ Cross - Even Body Attack - Whitaker Upper Body Head Movement - Whitaker Positioning/Using Angles - Whitaker Defense - Whitaker Ring Generalship - Whitaker Countering - RJ Stamina - Even Power - RJ Chin - Whitaker
Jab-whitaker hook-jones cross-whitaker body attack-whitaker upper body movement-whitaker angles-whitaker defense-whitaker ring generalship-whitaker countering-whitaker stamina-tie power-jones chin-whitaker
@southpawjab, in what world could you argue that Pea and Roy are equal in chin? It baffles me so completely ... the one thing that Pea proved way past his prime was that despite the coke issues, his chin was much more than solid. p4p, I'd much rather be hit by Tarver and Johnson than hit by Tito.
Jab - PW Left Hook/Right Hook - RJJ Cross - RJJ Body Attack - PW Upper Body Head Movement - RJJ, very very close Positioning/Using Angles - RJJ Defense - PW Ring Generalship - PW Countering - PW Stamina - PW Power - RJJ Chin - PW
Sorry for not breaking it down, but for me it's Whitaker. Jones was near superhuman at times athletically, but Pea was the more skilled, if not as outright freakish as Jones. When their physical advantages were taken away, it was Pea who performed better.
Chin : Whitaker Power : Roy Stamina: Even Mettle: Whitaker Strength: Even Recuperative powers: Even Oh... sorry you said skill.... My (and everyone else in this thread's) bad :good
Jab: Pernell Left Hook/Right Hook: Roy Cross: Pernell Body Attack: Pernell Upper Body Head Movement: Pernell Positioning/Using Angles: Pernell Defense: Pernell Ring Generalship: Even Countering: Pernell Stamina: Even Power: Roy Chin: Pernell
