My top 10 Heavyweights of all time.

Why is Lewis above Ali? My head hurts

 

SMITTY78, my arguement against your list (that I respectfully disagree with) is that you have Ali ranked #4 even though Ali is the only one on your list who beat any of your other top ten. Ali actually beat two fighters in your top ten whille noone else beat anyone else on your list. His quality of oposition based on the list YOU made should have him #1 or at leat #2 (louis and his 25 title defenses/11yr reign)

Add in the title defenses, being the best fighter in the era with the best heavyweight competition and it is hard for me to understand rating anyone but maybe Louis ahead of him. However, using YOUR list it seems that you would have Ali first. Please reply to this post as I am curious to hear your response.

 

Was Dempsey even # 1 in his own era? Dempsey fans are a dying breed these days, because Dempsey has been exposed by modern historians as a great fighter who accomplished far less than he should have, and doesn't belong in the top 10 all time.

 

How did incest come up?

 

I dont understand how people can have Tyson top 5. Just my personal opinion though.

 

I agree with this list 100%.

 

so wait, you ****ed your imaginary cousin in a kickboxing match? :huh

 

:roflthat's a **** of a tale man. if only any of it happened...

 

I like Sullivan in your top 10.

Foreman, I tend to put less weight on his second career than most others, so in part I agree with you; however, I would never call Foreman's KO of Moorer a 'lucky punch'. George looked for it, George worked for it, George seized the day when he got his chance -- The big man deserves respect for that.

 

Yes, but did you have sex with your cousin???

 

01 Ali
02 Louis

03 Holmes
04 Marciano

05 Lewis
06 Foreman
07 Dempsey

08 Holyfield
09 Johnson
10 Frazier

11 Tyson
12 Liston

:smoke

 

Thanks brother. I still can't bring myself to put Tyson in...maybe one day :hat