Is Jack Johnson the Greatest H2H Heavy of All Time?

Yes, Choynski was named hardest hitter by a few people from memory Jeffries, Johnson, Sharkey and someone else. The fact that a super middle is the biggest puncher of the era doesn't speak too highly for the punchers of that era. Choynski probably hits very hard but how would he feel next to a Tyson, Foreman even a Marciano or Dempsey (this is H2H and Johnson is a Heavy). I don't know whether Johson himself was a Super Middle but what I can say is that Johnson is naturally the far bigger man and I bet alot closer to 200lbs then Choynski. The Ketchel KD didn't look to dubious IMO and I don't see even the likes of Norton being decked by it.

Yes the supremely larger Johson KO'd Ketchel outweighing him by 35lbs not much to brag about there.
You say he KO'd Denver Ed Martin admitedly I know nothing of the man but a glance at his record doesn't go much in the way of adding anythign to Johnson's punching power.
Yes, he KO'd McVey when he was very young, inexperienced and outweighed.

You name all those names but seriously despite the fact they may be so and so tall and so and so heavy do they seriously compare to great modern fighters of the same dimensions? We are looking at Johnson H2H and Johnson being a heavy is gonna be against the likes of Ali, Holmes, Liston, Foreman, Tyson, Lewis etc. etc. Does his chin and punching power take him over the line against such opponents? Because his skill certainly won't.

 

Didn't say he was 200 but I said I bet he was alot closer to it then Choynski and that he was naturally the far bigger man.

From what I've seen of the punch seems legit, don't see much reason to fake a fall then KO the man cold the next second?

You say Johnson only scaled 185 the following year what about Choynski? Ranging from the low 160 to high 160's. Like I said Johnson is naturally the far bigger man.

Yes McVey was heavier but like I said inexperienced, young etc.

Ketchel was billed at 170 1/4. Not a heavyweight nor even a good sized light heavy. He was a super middle. None of which matters because as I said H2H were gonna be putting Johnson against men his own size not people 30 1/4lbs lighter.

Yes you have proved what I said to be incorrect let me rephrase and say Johnson never fought a proper sized heavyweight who was of high quality the kind of quality he'd be put up against like I said Tyson, Liston, Lewis, Ali, Holmes etc. Please do not say a young, inexperienced McVey or ancient Jeffries are of the same quality.