Calzaghe vs. Roy Jones who would win in their prime?

My brother argued that the result would be similar Calzaghe would slap and run. I argued my case and then he said 'it might be close'.

In my opinion Roy Jones completely destroys Calzaghe on points, in his prime, or by a first round KO.

Calzaghe is over hyped in the UK in my opinion he beat a un-prime Chris Eubank, where Eubank lost his following two fights and retired. No one else really stands out on his record. I hate that people think he is a 'legendary great fighter'

Please vote on the poll. Really want to know what you guys think.

 

inb4 the euros

 

Bro there's already a mega-thread on this.

 

Sorry man. Must have missed it. You got a link?

 

[url]http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=400841[/url]

 

I just seen this:
[url]http://www.***********.com/forums/showthread.php?t=331677[/url]
***********

Jones 74.62%
Calzaghe 25.38%

lol @ 25%. Should be lower

 

No pole on that one. Shall I keep this thread alive get a percentage? Or ask a mod to kill it?


Mods kill the thread.

 

Roy takes this.

 

roy all the way
the only reason this is a fantasy matchup is because someone who will remain anonymous (but he lives in wales....) didnt go make it happen

 

First sentence is correct.

The rest of the post is BS.

 

tell me why you think that?

 

Roy is (was) just too good at 168.


More speed, skills, power.

I'm a fan of Joe, but Roy was on a different level.

 

i meant why did you think the rest of the post was BS?

 

Rjj 116-112.