Top 30 fighters P4P from 1980-present

Nothing I was making it up

 

Don't out him on here as well luf!!! I feel bad about it as it is :-(

 

I outed no-one :bart

 

Thankfully there are screen shots. But honestly i'm afraid for my safety.

 

:rofl F'n Hell Luf atsch But still, smooth.

 

luf is as smooth as they com

 

Mayweather vs. McCallum resume comparison based on their ability at the time they fought the men they did:

Mayweather.....vs.....McCallum
No equivalent.............Toney
No equivalent..............Kalambay
DLH...........................Curry (Floyd had a size disadvantage, but I'd still say that Curry was in better nick than DLH)
Castillo.......................No equivalent
Corrales......................Jackson
Hatton........................Harding
Cotto.........................Watson
Mosley........................Collins
JMM............................McCrory
Hernandez...................No equivalent
Judah.........................Graham
Vargas........................No equivalent
Chavez.......................Braxton
Baldomir......................No equivalent
Manfredy.....................No equivalent
Gatti...........................Minchillo
Corley.........................No equivalent


Overall I'd say they are pretty even.

Floyd has more depth, Mike has more quality at the top end.

Floyd is more 'dominant', of course throw a ROy Jones level fighter at him at this stage and that nonsense stops right now.

Mike's loss to Kalambay in his prime is more honourable than what I take to be Mayweather's defeat to Castillo, given than Kalambay was the better fighter ability wise.
I also, perhaps deludely think that the DLH fight wasn't a clear win for Floyd, so that down grades his performance there.

As far as the Toney trilogy goes, 201 for Toney there, Mike taking the second.

 

I had the De La Hoya fight very close and found Floyd's application in the 2nd half possible due to Oscar's decline (never had 12 round stamina) and ditching of the jab.

 

He definitely faded down the stretch, as was his custom, although the 12th round was a decent round you could argue he won.

Overall I just found Mayweather's performance underwhelming.

Of course, a pot shotter will always look bad against a guy with a turtle shell D.

Hence his efforts against DLH & Cotto.

 

How about Gilberto Roman?

 

Roman was class as well, in that mix. Less efficient than Laciar though IMO, shorter prime and handled Kongtoranee less well than Khaosai. Lacier has the longevity even if their series was close. Roman was pretty one dimensional IMO, damn good at what he did of course. Past it by the time he faced Moon but a horrible matchup for him at any time.

He'd be up there. On Konadu's level moreso IMO. I have Roman-Watanabe on my channel and the Payakaroon fight will be up later today :thumbsup

 

Mayweather and Chavez a few places too high. Whitaker below Mayweather. ??

 

As promised

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AR8IzyPCVL0&feature=youtube_gdata_player[/ame]