Who Ranks higher on the ATG LIST. Julio Cesar Sr or Floyd Mayweather Jr?

The one with the superior resume. Because he's more proven against better opposition.

 

hey puta, take it easy on Chavez cabron. he's the best us mexicanos ever had, ****er. and hes the GOAT.

how does that foo floyd rank ahead when he only has 42 fights and Chavez had twice as many?

 

So if someone has a better resume it automatically means they have superior skills atsch

 

Mayweather in a "pure boxing" scense. I picked Sr.

 

chavez, from what i know

 

Bingo. :good

9.5 times/10 this is the case.

A boxer being more proven against a higher caliber of opposition = a greater boxer than one who isn't.

simple as that.

 

Floyd for his skill set and only having one gift decision, unlike JCC.

 

That being said Floyd also had far fewer fights to be able to get gift decisions.

 

Not even close, and this board is packed full of *****s.

 

Again people wow by large numbers. JCC fought mexican's finest bums 90% of his career. His resume is more padded than a flat chested jr high girl.

 

Close call

I go with Mayweather.

I think 20 years from now, people will laugh at how low people ranked Mayweather during his time.

 

So i guess pac has better skills than floyd because pac has the better resume?:think

Morales, Marquez@130 and Barrera are better than anything on floyds resume.

 

Pac lost to 2 of them guys

 

Chavez Sr by some distance at the minute but Floyd is still active (kind of) so he could push it close.

I'd pick Floyd to beat him if they fought though, at any weight.