Dempsey vs Wills with a twist

Yeah, I agree. With no colour line, Willard likely doesn't even turn pro...Wills wan't the real deal by my reckoning until just before Dempsey became the champ (maybe a year or so before) but i'm prepared to be corrected on that.

I think Langford would have been Johnson's #1 contender at some point when he started to slip, and once he started to slip it is likely that Langford would have beaten him.

Of course, it's not so simple. Maybe Johnson would have matched Langford instead of Jeffries (who likely wouldn't have come out of retirement) in 1910 and rinsed him bad. That might have eliminated him all together.

 

Then again, maybe with no colour line, Jeffries thrashes Johnson in 1905 and Johnson is eliminated!

 

Johnson loved the high life of course, so he may have started to slip regardless. But the enormous stress placed upon him and his migrant lifestyle were obviously factors. I wonder if it's possible he reigns until Wills is ready for him or even beyond?

 

1904: Jeffries beats Johnson then retires.
1905: Marin Hart beats Jack Root
1906: Jack Johnson beats Hart (after eliminating Burns)
1907: Jack Johnson beats Jeanette
1908: Jack Johnson beats McVey
1909: Jack Johnson beats Sam Langford
1910: Jack Johnson beats Joe Jeanette
1911: Jack Johnson beats Stanley Ketchel

Who or what am I missing?

 

Who do you think Jeffries would name?

 

You know what I think? I think maybe Dempsey and Wills might not fight for the title anyway. An eliminator looks more likley to me right now.

Who thinks maybe Jeffries would stick around long enough to shut Munro's trap anyway and a new champion isn't crowned until 1906? Maybe then it would be someone other than Root and Hart.

 

Mmmmm, well yeah, but he lost a strange one in twelve, had only been a pro three years and looked pretty vulnerable versus the best at the end of 1914. In '13 he made a couple of draws. Maybe it was right they told him no? Maybe the original dynamite crew is positioned for a second run at the title? But I ain't even got that far yet.

For sure, Wills lifting the title before Dempsey goes on his KO run to the title would be tidy.

But Wills went 2-2-2 in fights confirmed as scheduled for more than 10 rounds in 1914 and failed to beat Langford, Jeanette and McVey (0-2-2), according to Boxrec. This is not contender form I don't think.

 

Unless i'm missing something, Wills is 0-1-1 against Langford at the end of 1914. It would be 1916 before he would take a lead against Sam - maybe Sam would wave goodbye to him before that, seeing it your way?

If there's a counter-argument it's that Wills wouldn't be drawn into a series with Langford this early in his career.

But not everyone can be perfectly promoted just because there is no colour line.

 

I just don't think that Johnson and Jeffries would ever get along well enough for Jim to name him - and after he beats him up he wouldn't be all that acceptable as a championship contender in that era, I don't think.

I think he'd name the same dudes. But you never know.