The top 30 (at least) at each weight , including P4P

:yep

 

Somewhwere below top 30 HW and inside top 70 for sure . Didn't I rank him already in this thread ?
He was stoppable , but not as easy as Louis , Patterson and Ellis were. Actually everyone is stoppable , the question is how easy is it ?

 

A few worthy quotes just 2 demonstrate d depth of transvestism of some of d posters who posted in here :
HoeSlagSkank's thread "Pick a light-heavy to beat Vitali " :
http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=303345
after his reply in my thread of Byrd vs. Griffin :

TrashTrampSlut should have known d answer as he claims that no one loves Byrd more than he does .
Now lets c some lufcrazy's brilliance :
right in Boilermaker's thread about Chris Byrd :
http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=340703
but here is d most important part of it :
http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10649543&postcount=8
or in nested quoted form :

Now , lufcrazy of course did not reply to this , he was busy fixing his eyebrows and doing wax :yep .
Just like he didn't reply 2 this :

 

Now these r not ownages of those who posted them , just part of d reason 2 why Walker Smith Jr. is not a top 10 p4p but rather just a great (probably d greatest) h2h fighter @ either 147 , 154 or 160 . Just 2 keep it real .
:

Now think of what would've happened if Smith had 2 deal with a 6'2" Sammy Angott , while also giving in 6 years of age at d process . Would he have lasted d distance then ? now what about a 6'4" , 22 years old Henry Armstrong while Smith was 31 ?
It is only fair and counts as long as the idol/hero has d fair/unfair advantage .
Smith fought great and very good fighters in many of his fights , but he never had to face the advantages he had over his opponents . The closest he ever came to it , was after cherrypicking Joey Maxim instead of Archie Wright , and it ended by "Maxim TKO14 Robinson" . Smith was 31 at that time , not so old even for his era , and especially not so old considering he fought very good opponents for more than a decade after , but he did it again while being the big man . This is not so shocking in p4p terms . Or should Vitali and George Foreman get a bump up the p4p rankings just to keep matters fair ?

 

since sex appeal , public impact , commercial success , heritage , legacy , longevity and influence r such important ,
dis mast b mor popular :


1. Peter North - despite not being 1 of my favorites since long ago
____ his big kok , sex appeal , public impact , charisma and popularity r undeniable , longevity and title defenses also plenty in abundant .

___ can some1 honestly claim that he never watched Peter North at work ?
__ workmanlike , perhaps 2 much ,

2. John Holmes - haven't seen him at work , admittedly , not from my era , but i read heroic legends about him .
_____ but as u noticed i m not a big fan of vintage

___ i read that he had a beautiful receptive wife , Misty Dawn , a big kok and n undeniable impact on d industry

3. Alex Sanders - relaxed , focused , s generalship like his r rare 2day , Phyllisha Ann's realife hubby

4. Manuel Ferrara - this guy obviously has d fire & desire , focus as well

5. Ben Dover - gr8est British per4mer OAT , perhaps putting him this low does him injustice

6. Seymore Butts - huge longevity and volume of work , not a big kok , though

7. Christoph Clarke - i read tales of gr8ness about him back in d day

8. Rocco Siferedi - brought Manuel Ferara 2d business , but had his own influence

9. Ron Jeremy - hairiest big phatt kok ever

10. Max Hardcore - d real scatman

11. Joey Silvera - read a lot about him

12. John Stagliano - Buttman stole his alias , Tricia Devereaux husband , + AIDS

13. Nacho Vidal - seemingly workmanlike , tenacious and fiery all in 1 , BellaDona's realife hubby

14. Mr. Marcus - d Jack Johnson of d business

15. Sean Michaels - d Peter Jackson of d industry

16. Kid Bengala - D Harry Wills of d business , though he reminds me a lot of Glen Johnson . D face behind kreizi manster kok .

17. Brandon Iron - 1 doesn't need 2b big 2b hard

18. Dick Nasty - i've heard some of d **** he does may b fun 2 some

19. Dick Rambone - u've probably know i'm a big 1980s fan by now
__ if your grandchildren rid dis , tel dem dick means litel richard

20. Marc Dorcel - yet another frenk QT , was a big star back in his dei


21. Hakkan Serbes - there is a group dedic8ed 2 him on another forum , 1 of 2day's representatives in d list

22. Ben English

23. Lexington Steele - d Lee Q Murray of d business , probably under8ed in dis list

24. Jules Jordan - BBC4life

25. Mark Davis - influential , but still perhaps 2 high , Cing some of him might have caused some personal bias 2 his favor

26. ManDingo - yet another BBC

27. Herschell Savage - well , he made it after all , at least 4 now

28. Voodoo - just 4 being Nicole Sheridan's rilife hubby , marrying rait is also a criteria !

29. Randy West - how did i 4get him thus far ? maybe bikoz he ain't from my gener8ion

30. Vince Voyeur - probably would b higher in d next edit(ion)


31. Jack "There's something about" Napier

 

Could b edited and changed in d future , so far just a sketch .

118 (Bantamweight) :
1. Eder Jofre
2. Pete Herman
3. Fidel LaBarba
4. Pete Sandstol
5. Sixto Escobar
6. Carlos Zarate
7. Jorge Lujan
8. Chucho Castillo
9. Rafael Herera
10. Ruben Olivares

11. Jose Medel
12. Masahiko Harada
13. Joe Lynch
14. Memphis Pal Moore
15. Manuel Ortiz
16. Lou Salica
17. Harry Jeffra
18. Baltazar Sangchili
19. Orlando Canizales
20. Horacio Acavallo

21. Nonito Donaire
22. Anselmo Moreno
23. Vakhtang Darchiniyan

126 (Feather) :

1. Salvador Sanchez
2. Ernesto Marcel
3. Juan LaPorte
4. Eder Jofre
5. Tony Canzoneri
6. Jimmy McLarnin
7. Luisito Espinosa
8. Fidel LaBarba
9. Willie Pep
10. Henry Melody Jackson

11. Johhny Famechon
12. Azumah Nelson
13. Barry McGuigan
14. Alexis Arguello
15. Erik Morales
16. Juan Manuel Marquez
17. Marco Antonio Barera
18. Emmanuel Paquiao
19. Naseem Hamed
20. Eusebio Pedroza

21. Wilfredo Gomez
22. Antonio Cermeno
23. Antonio Esparagoza
24. Rafael Ortega