THE RING P4P LIST HAS BEEN UPDATED. Congrats to Andre Ward & Anselmo Moreno.

Epic fail. That link does not point to P4P ratings prior to June 2012. Try again...

 

I'd have Ward at the top.

After Pac's loss to Bradley (even if controversial), I'd bring him down from 2 to 4 behind Floyd and Nonito.

1. Ward
2. Floyd
3. Nonito
4. Marquez
5. Pac
6. Wlad
7. Martinez
8. Froch
9. Vitali
10. Bradley

I was tempted to put Rigo in at 8

 

you're the epic fail. how can you explain that bradley was already 102 weeks on that p4p list?

 

I had Bradley in my p4p list for a while, but I remember last year having to argue with people over who should be rated higher, Cotto or Bradley and I was saying Bradley

this is all ****ed up :nut

 

Why are people bringing up 2008 like it matters to current P4P rankings :nut

 

where the **** is froch

 

indeed

 

The argument in favor of Martinez and Donaire is that they have continued to win. The philosophy of THE RING Editorial Board is that fighters generally must falter to lose their positions in the ratings. Martinez and Donaire haven’t really faltered.

That’s why Manny Pacquiao remains tied with Floyd Mayweather Jr. at the top of our pound-for-pound ratings. As we wrote previously, we didn’t feel he should be punished for narrowly outpointing a fellow superstar in Juan Manuel Marquez (even if the result was controversial) and handling unbeaten Tim Bradley.

Is it just me or is this paragraph ******ed?

 

Manny faltered (officially) in his last fight and they did not dock him.

Manny faltered (unofficially) last November and they did not dock him.

 

I have to agree here, although I have Moreno/Mares a toss up.

I take all of these rankings with a grain of salt. They are highly subjective.

 

I don't understand why anyone would have a vacated #1 spot on their list. That's telling me the judge of the list expects to see abilities and accomplishments far beyond reason. A P4P list is more of a neverending race than anything. In a foot race do you say the guy who is winning isn't #1 just because he isn't running fast enough for you? Ridiculous. If you think Floyd doesn't deserve the top spot due to his inactivity then just give it to Ward, ffs.

 

so those 2 pounds mattered? cause ya'll claim 2 pounds didnt matter in the cotto fight

 

i was thinking the exact same thing then i seen your post

 

About time Moreno was in!

 

I can't understand how Moreno is ahead of Mares p4p. Somebody has an explanation?