Is Mayweather an ATG?

already an ATG and has been for many a year now bro

i hope youre trolling

 

Most will probably say yes, I'm not so sure. He has never been in a FOTY, that's not too good. He has not fought anyone for years who was a legit threat. I'd say HOF material.

 

He's also been at the top of the p4p rankings for god knows how many years. Whether you love him or you hate him, he is an ATG.

 

We shall call him; The Uncrowned Champion. One of the Greatest to ever lace them up. A Real Hero.

 

It's the ultimate stupidity to say no.

Of course he is.

 

FOTY usually involve back-and-forth fights and/or are very competitive. Floyd's not involved in those type of fights because he's better than his opponents by a wide margin. As such, his fights tend to be one-sided. That's not his fault.

He is an ATG. How high on the list is debatable, but clearly beneath top 10.

 

Nah, I don't buy that, he picks his fights well, that's all.

 

Yea he is. He overrated, but still ATG.

 

So did the second best heavyweight of all time, to hold on to a title that was worth virtually nothing in the end, yet you wouldn't question him as an ATG. Give me a well structured argument to why Mayweather isn't an ATG.

 

Money dont play that rockem sockem robot **** and that's mostly what foty is all about. However he has been named fighter of the year several times. The man is an ATG and that can't be denied.:bbb

 

He is only the best boxer for the last 20 years. That's all.

 

He's not even HOF worthy

ATG cherrypicker and ducker that's what he is

and he lost to Castillo I

 

Easy. Since 140 he has fought beatable opposition and retired while 147 was steaming hot. He has beat no one that has not been beaten better.

 

Of course not. A Hall of Famer maybe, but an ATG?