Andre Ward vs These Past Super Middleweight's

Out of them all and in thier prime, I would go for Benn he was savage and I have seen both Benn Eubank fights live.
Andre Ward is a very skilled SMW and I ( even as a Brit ) hope he reigns for quite some time before moving up in weight, if there is any money fight up there for him..

 

He loses to 11 of them and maybe all of them.

He loses to

Joe Calzaghe prime
James Toney prime
Roy Jones Jr prime
Chris Eubank prime
Nigel Benn prime
Michael Watson prime
Steve Collins prime
Mike McCallum prime
Iran Barkley prime
Michael Nunn prime
Chong - Pal Park prime
Murray Sutherland prime is a toss up

 

Joe Calzaghe: Calzaghe SD
James Toney: Toney UD
Roy Jones Jnr: Jones TKO 10
Chris Eubank: Ward UD
Nigel Benn: Ward UD
Michael Watson: Ward UD
Steve Collins: Ward UD
Mike McCallum: Ward UD
Iran Barkley: Ward UD
Michael Nunn: Ward UD
Chong-Pal Park: Ward KO 9
Murray Sutherland: Ward UD

 

Ward makes Benn and Barkley look absolutely foolish.

 

This, although I think he SD's Calzaghe and possibly loses to the very best versions of Nunn and McCallum.

 

You're overrating Andre Ward drastically. Most of them have a fairly decent chance in knocking out Ward.

Andre Ward would be tailor made for Nigel Benn.

 

Yeah these fans now at days.See a solid undefeated fighter like floyd,ward,broner & think he's unbeatable.I've seen ward get shook & hurt by lesser names i'm sure rugged guys from the past would hang with him & then some.He takes a couple if not handful of losses to those guys.Today vs that era no comparison.

 

Froch would stop Benn late in a war and Kessler would jab his head off. Benn was by and large a crude slugger that could occasionally box decently to a gameplan. You need more dimensions than that to beat Ward at his best.

 

Loses to Jones without question. Could potentially lose to a few others (Toney who I'd favor, Calzaghe who I think would drop a close one to Ward, etc), but he'd have a reasonably solid chance at any of them aside from Roy. Some he'd flat-out beat widely like Barkley. McCallum was a better fighter than Ward at his prime, but I don't know if I'd fancy his chances that much at 168. Nunn, for all his physical talents, gets outhustled and outdone over 12. Watson would be a nice tactical match and somebody like Benn and McClellan would have puncher's chances.

 

Fitzsimmon's KO1 Ward

 

This.. Except I think he'll last the distance against Jones and give him a pretty tough fight

 

Roy Jones jr & James Toney would of been great fights.. Andre Ward beats the rest!

 

Near enough how I see it.

Only variation is that I see Calzaghe winning close but clearly.

 

He beats Chris Eubank?

And Nigel Benn?

I dunno about that one. I think Nigel Benn and Chris Eubank fought superior competition for a long time and did the business.

I think Andre Ward is being vastly overrated if you compare the competition from now against the competition Eubank and Benn were fighting against.


He's a good fighter but he is being overrated now.