Is Floyd Mayweather Jr the greatest undefeated fighter? Discuss

sergio has not fought at 154 in 5 years

trout is the best at 154 based on what exactly?

 

clown

 

floyd's O is hollow.

 

Bro, YDKSAB!


COTTO was un-shot when he fought Floyd, and was shot again against Trout. :-(

 

how exactly?

 

my bad you're right about Pac. But what cherry picks are you talking about?

Genaro?
Castillo?
Gatti? (Hatton and Tsyzu were busy fighting eachother. Then Hatton and Cotto didn't want to fight Floyd at 140)
Judah?
Baldomir?
Oscar?
Ortiz?
Cotto?

 

154: Miguel Cotto - good win

147: Victor ortiz - where does he rank 147 all time or 147 at the time.

147: Shane Mosley - Rank this win according to the point in time of Shane's career.

147: JMM - against a 130 lbs fighter. Where does JMM rank ATG at 147?

147: Hatton - Where does Hatton rank ATG 147

154: ODLH - Rank this win according to the point in time of ODLH's career.

147: Baldomir- Where does Baldo rank ATG 147

147: Sharmba Mitchell - 5'0 Little big man -Where does he rank 147 ATG?

140 -Gatti, Bruseles, Corley


135: Ndou - eh

135: Castillo II - ran the entire fight

135: - Castillo I - Castillo got robbed

130: Chavez - good win

130: Corrales - good win

135: Augustus - eh

130: Juuko - eh

130: Vargas - who?

130: Manfredy - decent win

130: Chicanito - RIP - It was Chicanito's last fight


He is hardly the ATG he and his fanboys claim to be...

 

nonnono

 

Can someone ban this clown from making the same twenty threads every day.

 

pretty much. I can't think of someone that is undefeated and can top what he did.

 

Floyd needs a loss to be considered great

 

Name me the jr lightweights that can move up over time to jmw and win a title fight against a top rated jmw like Hoya while giving up at least 15pds?

Hell name me the jr light weights, light weights, & jr welters right now that could move up over the same time frame and beat Baldomir giving up 18pds on fight night?

There was another thread talking about how Morales and Barrera were to small for Mayweather. Yet Mayweather gave up 9pds to Castillo as a lightwieght. Gave up 10pds to Corrales on fight night. Gave up 18pds to Baldomir, 15pds to Hoya. Dude been fighting above his weight range for yrs. Greats like Morales, Pac, Barrera and many others starved themselves for yrs to try and have the size advantage.

So while there werent any greats to fight at least he put himself in a size disadvantage which he didn't have to do. At the same time Cotto top 3 JMW, Ortiz #2 WW, Mosley #1 WW, Marquez #2 p4p, Hatton top 5 WW #5 p4p, ODLH #2 JMW, Baldomir lineal champ, Ibf, Wbc, & Ring title holder, top 2 WW, Judah top 3 WW, top 6 p4p, Mitchell tune up, Gatti #2 JR WW, Corley & Bruceless title eliminators etc etc etc.

 

it is easy to make excuses.

Out of your list. Most of the fighters that he fought are coming off wins. a lot of the fighters also went on to become champions again. Floyd hasn't fought anyone irrelvant for a very long time now.

 

you forgot to mention Hatton was coming off a recent loss to Luis collazo just not on paper before Floyd had the balls to fight him.

 

Pretty much all of them were coming off of losses quitting or recent bad performances.


Floyd mayweathers best wins were Castillo 2 and corales