If Floyd retires this year after beating Guerrero and Canelo

Yup 10-15 definitely is where he belongs if he beats Guerrero/Canelo (A beast at 154)

Haters gon hate. :bbb

PBF for life.

 

A lot of hall of famers on that list

 

Ten to fifteen sounds fair I'm not even a Floyd fan but people who hate on him are morons

 

10-15? No. Obviously not, anyone that doesn't have Floyd's dick in their mouth will tell you the likes of Guerrero and Canelo don't suddenly make you hang with SRL.

 

SRL had multiple losses although some ATG quality wins

Was never a 9 time world champion, 4 time lineal champion. Undefeated. Greatest Punchstat record for a fighter.

SRL ranks ahead but Floyd deserves 10-15.

SRL 11, Floyd 14

 

Who you beat is what matters. SRL beat better fighters. So did a bunch of ATG's.

 

atsch Lineal cus Canelo took the title from the most feared Jr Middleweight Matthew Hatton

 

Gotta take into account his longevity too. Other fighters have won world championship fights 15 or even more years apart. No fighter has EVER done it without sustaining a single blemish on his record, and off the top of my head, no fighter has EVER stayed undefeated over a 17-year stretch in total.

Still not so sure about top-15 ATG though... that's a lot of great fighters you have to top...

 

Yes you are, just because your original user name was suspended and you have no created an alt that doesnt mean we cant see right through you

 

But he's had his fair share of losses.

Floyd beat ATGS/HOFS his whole career. 20+ world title fights, and just can't lose.

17 year stretch undefeated

Beat all his contemporaries besides Pacquiao because Pacquiao ducked the **** out of him.

 

A great record what could of been better.

 

Well the thing is there are no official rules regarding title lineage.
In the case of the 154-pounders, Winky Wright was undiputed champ and left the division without losing that status in the ring, and no fighter since then has definitively estasblished himself as the man at that weight since then..

Wouldn't Mayweather-Canelo be a good fight to re-establish the lineage? Although that only goes as long as one of them beats Trout first, i admit.

 

He ducked the biggest fight out there against a midgit:deal

He ducked a DLH re-match:deal

He'll not go down as a legend, far to many *****

He's a fine technician, But?????...see above.

 

Never beat anyone as good as Duran, Hearns, Benitez, or Hagler. So it's irrational to rank him higher.