The Top 100 Pound for Pound All-Time Greats

Didn't he lose to Stanley twice and also drop a decision to joe bowker

 

Yes and?

 

It's a beautiful day the bird are singing and the sun is shinning

 

Just having some fun double M.
This is an excellent thread evinced ,[good word] by how many pages its gone to. You have most if not all of the usual suspects good picks!

 

Nothing, being serious

The bowker fight would of an excellent example to have on film as both bowker/Moran were well skilled examples of boxers for their time

And Stanley vs Moran would of been interesting as Stanley was not exactly known for playing by the rules

 

I'm just playing devils advocate really. No one can provide a definitive 100, but this list seems as good as any ,and a sight better than most. It's provoked discussion, and prompted a re-evaluation of some guys who have fallen into obscurity, and that can only be a positive.:good

 

Devil's advocate is cool :yep, and I agree a definitive top 100 is pretty much impossible

 

Horrible arrangement atsch

 

Your allowed your opinion no matter how atsch it is

 

So you do have a top 100?

 

No I usually stay clear of lists that are more than twenty always second guessing myself :yep ,and really have in the past stayed within weight classes. as I think I mentioned earlier have been pretty ill for the last few months and was doing a fifty to keep myself busy . Then saw this thread and tweaked my list a bit I posted it the other day on another site not fantastically different to this one in names . Lists really aren't my thing as I say they are easily second guessed as a difference of ten to fifteen places can be wafer thin

 

Oh ok, I thought I saw you mention you had one of McG's guys "around 86 on your list" so I figured you had a list made up.

 

I might of mentioned either your man Oscar at the mark or even one of my men (berg)for that position I would like berg higher than 86 but after seeing this list come together i can't really honestly do that but 86 for berg I would prefer but the margins between fighters is as I say wafer thin so no complaints from me