critique my Lightweight rankings

For my taste I would have

Duran No. 1
Whitaker should move up at least a few spots
Armstrong down out of the top 10... He has the h2h ability but his resume is pretty paltry at this weight.
J.C.C. up a few spots
I like Mosley up some because of his h2h ability
JMM down

 

Now I know you didn't just suggest placing Armstrong outside the top ten.

 

Mosley gets in on 'H2H' and Armstrong doesn't despite beating **** loads of quality fighters whilst weighing in around 135lbs.

But yeah, Holiday>Ambers

 

Since when does "moving up some" mean he makes it to the top ten? Some doesn't mean over 10 spots. I was thinking more like moving up 5 spots. Armstrong could be in there.. though.. I have him around 10 or 11.. Looking at it and factoring in a little more points for h2h.. he's okay around 8.

 

We should read and comprehend before laughing big buddy.

 

Nowt wrong with my comprehending skills, I thought what he said was funny so I laughed.

 

It's ****.

 

If this were H2H I would share your sentiments here.

But don't you think Hank's resume at LW is pretty thin comparatively?

 

Castillo should be higher than Marquez.

 

Mayweather is way too high, and this is coming from someone who actually rate Floyd quite well most of the times....

 

Jjust playing Philly, I like it, but I agree Castillo should be higher than Marquez. Good shout Vic!

 

Gans at #2 is also quite gutsy :yep

 

Ambers, Wright, Arizmendi (x2), Bass, Day, Feldman (x2), Ghnouly, Klick, Spoldi, Chavez (x2)

Nothing thin about that win list

 

Oscar too low also :nono