The Top 100 Pound for Pound All-Time Greats

Yeah but Wilde is ahead for P4P achievements.

Harada>Olivares, surely?

 

You want me to give it a go when I'm home for work?

And have I said that already then?

 

Yeah give it a go hopefully it might work and it will be a good read

 

Compare Whitaker's wins vs Mayweather's potential wins

Whitaker vs Mayweather
J.C.Chavez - Pacquiao (a recovered Pacquiao who is as good as he was against Marquez) - I pick Pacquiao. Pacquiao even beats Chavez H2H

Nelson - Marquez = Marquez. Nelson was at 135 - Marquez would lose if he was prime 160 - so I don't use the 'Marquez was made to move up too quickly' BS argument. Also JMM beats Nelson H2H

Vasquez - Martinez or Canelo/Trout winner (?) = Probably Vasquez slightly

McGirt - J.L.Castillo = ???

Oscar - Oscar = prime Oscar obviously.

Haugen - Cotto = Cotto

J.L.Ramirez - Corrales - I pick Corrales. Ramirez was at the end of a packed career.

Rest of resume vs Rest of resume - Mayweather wins

H2H ability = Whitaker

Longevity = Mayweather

+ Mayweather is arguably the greatest superfeatherweight of all time, at a young age.
vs
Whitaker is one of the best lightweights of all time, although his opponents were not special.

If Mayweather gets wins against a RECOVERED Manny who is as good as he was against Marquez in 4th fight, Canelo-Trout or Martinez...Mayweather's overall career deserves to be up there with Whitaker.


Right now: Mayweather = 40's.

 

If you're talking about FH vs Olivares for p4p ranking..I'd definitely want to hear. I'm studying FH atm.

 

I'm Flea but being mistaken for the mighty El Bujia is a compliment even if accidental

Anj didn't you get loads of info' on Harada the other week fella? What else you dug up?

 

Also seeing as Gavilan is so highly ranked and I've made the case for Chang I've uploaded one of the alltime most controversial bouts (Gavilan Vs Sexton, **** me is it boring) and The Korean Hawk at his arguable peak Vs Chitalada.

Might help everyone bet a better grasp/more or less appreciation/more context etc etc etc

 

I know you think I'm on your case but this is a pointless post.

 

Yup I have when I watched the Jofre fights and the Rudkin fight last week. I've been holding back from talking about Harada whenever I saw his name bump up on this thread, and will continue to do so until I can throw it all out on an Official Fighting Harada Thread. Right now I can't find the Herrera-Harada fight anywhere, so I'm just going to read up on it, learn more about Herrera and move onto Medel 2.

I could have done a better job with my note taking for the Jofre fights. Was just so pissed that I lost what I wrote for the Kingpetch fights although I remember the main points.

Which fights did you say you had that can't be found anywhere?

 

I didn't say

 

Just trying to create the best case I can for Mayweather lol

 

? Have you not got them? Would be a shame but there's still a good amount of footage compared to a Greb