the what fights did you watch today\scorecard thread.

Well thats a fight im not going to watch so:yep

if you've ever watched Norwood-Marquez, probably surpasses this fight, not only do you have a horrible clash of styles and zero activity, you've got one of the dirtiest SOB's in Norwood to enter the ring in this era in it:good

 

Gaspar Ortega-Jorge Fernandez would have been the greatest fight ever!

 

OK guys I'm softening my stance on official results, I feel they are more important than I previously considered.

Basically I would hold my own card above the result no matter how close, now I think if it can be scored for the man who got the official nod, the result should stand.

This is my list of controversial fights I've scored over the past and felt were worth keeping for future discussion.

If anyone can be arsed helping me out here, I'd like to know which should be in the category of "robbery" and which should be in the category of "official result is feasible"

....
Adamek L12 Cunningham (u)
Adamek L12 Chambers (u)

Ali L15 Norton (u)
Ali W15 Young (o)

Alexander L12 Kotelnik (u)
Alexander L12 Matthyse (u)

Antuofermo L15 Hagler (u)

Barrera L12 Morales 2 (u)
Barrera L12 Marquez (o)

Basilio W15 Saxton 1 (u)

Bowe L12 Holyfield 2 (o)

Byrd W12 oquendo (o)
Byrd D12 Golotan (o)
Byrd W12 McCline (o)

Castillo L12 Mayweather (o)

Camacho L12 Mancini (close)
Camacho L12 Rosario (close)
Camacho L10 Duran 1 (close)

Casamayor W12 Corrales (u)

Charles L10 Johnson (o)

Cunningham W12 Wlodarczyk (u)

Darchinyan W12 Mares (u)

De la Hoya W12 Quartey (o)
De la hoya W12 Mosley 2 (u)
De la hoya W12 Trinidad (u)
De la hoya L12 Sturm (u)

Diaz L12 Malignaggi (u)

Eubank L12 Benn 2 (u)

Esparagoza L12 Villasana (close)

Freitas W12 Casamayor (o)

Foreman L12 Briggs (o)
Foreman D12 Schulz (u)

Foster L15 Ahumada (u)

Froch L12 Kessler (o)
Froch W12 Dirrell (o)

Garcia L10 Armstrong (close)

Griffith L15 Rodriguez 3 (u)

Hagler L12 Leonard (o)

Harada W15 Kingpetch (close)

Hernandez W12 Ross (o)

Holyfield L12 Lewis 1 (u)
Holyfield L12 Moorer (o)

Holmes W12 Witherspoon (o)
Holmes W15 Williams (o)
Holmes L15 Spinks 1 (o)

Hopkins L12 Taylor 1 (o)
Hopkins W12 Mercado (u)
Hopkins L12 Calzaghe (o)

Huck D12 Afolabi 1 (u)
Huck D12 Afolabi 2 (o)
Huck D12 Arslan (u)
Huck W12 Lebedev (o)

Judah L12 Matthyse (u)

Leonard L12 Hearns 2 (u)

Martinez W12 Cintron (u)
Martinez W12 Williams 1 (u)

Marquez W12 John (u)
Marquez W12 Pac 1 (u)
Marquez L12 Pac 2 (o)

Morales L12 Barrera 1 (u)
Morales L12 Barrera 3 (o)

Mullings D12 Castillejo (u)

Nelson L12 Fenech 1 (u)

Norton W15 Young (o)
Norton L15 Holmes (o)

Norwood L12 Marquez (u)

Ottke L12 Reid (u)
Ottke L12 Mitchell (u)

Pacquiao L12 Marquez 3 (u)
Pacquiao W12 Bradley (u)

Pascal L12 Hopkins 1 (u)

Pedroza W15 Taylor (o)

Peter L12 Toney 1 (u)

Povetkin W12 Huck (o)

Ramirez L12 Whittaker 1 (u)

Randall W8 Chavez (close)

Rosario W12 Camacho (close)

Ruiz W12 Valuev 1 (u)
Ruiz L12 Golota (u)

Shibata L15 Marcel (u)

Spinks L15 Holmes 2 (u)

starling W12 Breland 1 (u)

Tarver W12 Johnson 1 (u)

Taylor D12 Hopkins 2 (u)

Toney L12 Tiberi (u)
Toney W12 McCallum 1 (o)
Toney L12 McCallum 2 (u)
Toney W12 Johnson (o)
Toney W12 Thadzi (u)

Tua L12 Rahman 2 (u)

Valuev L12 Holyfield (u)

Whittaker W12 Chavez (u)
Whittaker L12 De La Hoya (o)

Williams L12 Lara (u)

Wright W12 Vargas (u)

Zarate W15 Pintor (u)

 

You need to get on Kalule vs Gregory as soon as possible luf, one of those truly controversial must be seen and scored sort of fights.

 

Now, now!

 

I'm working division by division so that's gonna be a bit off yet but I'll add it to my list :good

 

Know, I was saying 'now, now' to Lora as in 'leave it out'.

I implore you to never watch it. I wish I'd taken Bujia's advice and not listened to mante'

 

haha I get ya, good man :good

 

I think we all can agree that barring a notoriously controversial Gregory fight Kalule basically finished his career as an undefeated phenom.

 

I gave Manny the 1st and last only.

Robbed against Leonard, McCallum and Graham but Moore won fair 'n' square.

 

Moore indeed troubled Kalule a bit.

But just because Kalule was as always an overwhelming favourite to win by a first round knockout and Moore performed slightly better than expected doesn't mean Moore deserved to win the fight.

Kalule is everybody's favourite and some people consider him a personal hero so I can understand your frustration
but let's not go overboard here.

Calm down, Flea.

 

o - official result matches
u - official result doesn't.

the one's without o/u I need to rewatch to be sure. The one's with "u" are where the result is unofficial and I need to see if the official result is reasonable or not.

 

Never beaten at his peak.

A true legend of featherfisted counterpunching.

 

Tell Jimmy Price that!