Your all-time best in each weight class

Here are mine:

Heavyweight: Muhammed Ali
Cruiserweight: Evander Holyfield
Light Heavyweight: Archie Moore
Super Middleweight: Joe Calzaghe
Middleweight: Harry Greb
Jr Middleweight: Thomas Hearns
Welterweight: Sugar Ray Robinson
Jr Welterweight: Julio Cesar Chavez
Lightweight: Roberto Duran
Jr Lightweight: Floyd Mayweather Jr
Featherweight: Willie Pep
Jr Featherweight: Wilfredo Gomez
Bantamweight: Carlos Zarate
Jr Bantamweight: Khaosai Galaxy
Flyweight: Jimmy Wilde
Jr Flyweight: Jung Koo-Chang
Strawweight: Ricardo Lopez

How about yours? :think

 

In head to head I agree with you on Roy Jones, but also head to head I would pick Lennox Lewis to beat Muhammed Ali, I'm talking about accomplishments I should of noted.

I went for Moore over Charles because I feel the losses to Moore came before he was in his prime because he also lost to fighters with less than stellar records like Henry Hall and Leonard Morrow, the fighter he became later has about 10 wins over the top 30 Light Heavyweights of all-time, won a world title at 36 and held it for nearly 10 years (coming down from Heavyweight to defend it).

 

I mentioned why I went Moore over Charles in my last post.

In a head to head list I'd have Jones at Super Middle without a doubt. But he didn't stay there for long enough to be ranked over Calzaghe and I believe he only had around 10 fights at 168, with his only meaningful win over James Toney.

Super Fly is probably the weakess division of all-time, I went for Galaxy over Tapia because he had 19 wins in world title fights compared to Tapia's 15, and I think the quality of his opponents was a little better as they included 7 world champions all of whom Galaxy beat by KO.

 

The other points I've covered in previous posts but regarding Greb, he fought most of his career with one good eye and has wins over 26 Hall of Famers. From what I've rwad his 2 looses to Tiger Flowers should have been wins too

 

As much as I dislike Mayweather I disagree. Pacquiao only had 8 fights at Jr Lightweight (although they was mainly against top fighters), Arguello would probably be 2nd on the list but Mayweather completely cleaned out the division against top class fighters and none of whom came close to giving him a fight (before anyone mentions Castillo-that was at Lightweight)

 

The manner of Mayweathers victories was more impressive though.