My Personal 25 Greatest of all times List.

Who didn´t though ? Tell me one ATG that didn´t look great at his best ??

 

He is one of my top H2H guys :smoke

That's why it doesn't work. Non ATGs look great at their best.

 

In a way that's what makes it more honest though.

Everyone into doing lists(arseholes all should aspire to do a peak inherent ability list.If only to see how much it differs from an attempt at a more balanced criteria(this only including fighters we're rating primariliy due to our thoughts on their footage not writing)

I don't think it should change THAT much imo, just a difference here and there...a drop or rise in places for a few etc.At least not if you're only going up to 50 or so.

Then things could change considerably after that.

 

What the McGreezy is sayin'

 

aye you're right if we're talking ALL fighters, it would make a massive difference.I was more meaning all the sufficiently filmed types, as i said.it would be unfair to penalise the others, so that's usually just who i'm referring to when talking those sort of lists and comparisons.

 

I wouldn't have the last three in my top 100.

They are all fighters that do better for me on a balanced list.

 

Actually make that top 80 or so.I forget how many would be taken out of the equation when we're just talking about filmed fighters.

 

Harada and Jofre ? Maybe not enough footage of Jofre though.......

 

Fair enough....one guy that I always think should be there with anyone in the "eye" criteria is Joey Archer....maybe I´m pushing it too far here ? Anyone else feel like Archer was absolute elite on film, in terms of skills and all ?

 

btw i went back through Morales whole career recently and thoroughly enjoyed it.Tried to re-assess him a bit.

A massively entertaining and really good, at times excellent fighter.But i don't see that sort of special talent some do.He certainly wouldn't have been a multi-weight champ above 126 without the junior classes and soft\fading champs to pick on and as a feather he's in the same rough bracket as the really good ones like the guys that surrounded Saldivar, danny Lopez(who i'd pick him to beatmore often than not) etc Really good, but quite flawed and an overachiever due to fighting in an era which favours such things as weightjumping and splinter champs.