When its all said and done Oscar de La Hoya will rank higher than Floyd Mayweather Jr

PBF is the better more skilled fighter he has Oscar beat in most departments. If you think Oscar is a more skilled fighter than PBF then you probably think Oscar is a more skilled fighter than Pea Whitaker as well and thus have no credibility.
Speed PBF
Reflexes PBF
Footwork PBF
Defense PBF
Power Oscar
Jab Oscar
Stamina PBF
Countering PBF
Ring IQ PBF
Chin Even
Heart PBF
Size Oscar

 

Nothing subjective about it. PBF went up and beat Oscar clearly.

 

You can be the most talented fighter that ever existed but if you refuse to take the best challenges out there you are not going to rank higher than a fighter who did take on the biggest and best challenges.

its not your skills that will place you in the history books its what you have done with those skills.
And Floyd has clearly avoided all the biggest threats while they were threats, while DLH took on those challenges head on win lose or draw he stepped up and fought a Prime Tito, Prime Quartey, Prime Hopkins, Prime Vargas.

 

what was the official decision? was it not a single point split decision? thats hardly beating someone clearly son

 

Whitaker shoulda won that fight, ****outtahere. I like how you credit him for beating a decrepit Chavez but give him a pass for getting his ass whipped by pac. You also left out that ass whippin by Sturm. He doesn't get a pass for gettin his ass taxed twice by Mosely either.

 

Biggest and best challenges huh? Are you talking Margo (cheater) and Pac (cheater/hype job)?

 

Guess what? He took a rather big challenge when he went up to fight Oscar at 154 on his terms and beat him. A fight that still gives you nightmares at night.:hi:

 

But in the same breath he discredits him because of a split decision. :rofl

 

PBF won that fight going away. 9-3 or 8-4 at worst. That bought and paid for GBP judge scored the 10th round for Oscar a round in which PBF clearly won that tells you everything you need to know about his card. But what can I say? You scored Rios-Abril for Rios. You can;t score a fight to save your life. Try telling this **** to someone who doesn't know any better I was back here schooling your ass when this fight happned and told you that PBF would win and you said he wouldn't.:deal

 

Mosley admitted to being on Steroids for the rematch why should I consider that a loss for DLH when before we even knew about this most viewed it as a DLH win.

Sturm, well all I got to say is that is a matter of opinion Sturm allowed Oscar to win too many of the early rounds, your not going to come here from Germany and think all you have to do is defend against a house hold name like DLH you better do more than just that.

Sturm gave away too many early rounds allowed Oscar to hit him at will to that mid section... if Felix Sturm couldnt do a damn thing with that fat version that out of shape version of DLH he deserved to lose cus he sure as **** didnt fight like a champion that night.

as far as Pacquiao come on now even Roach admitted DLH was drained and I am confident you believe that as well, However that win for Pac is about as good as Chavez rematch win over Taylor

 

So much controversy regarding Oscar bouts. What we do know is that the best opponent he clearly beat is Fernando Vargas. Or maybe Ike Quartey. And that's not that impressive.

 

And guess what your boy trying to pull a Pacquiao move with Canelo :hi:

Single point SD deal with it

 

Wow the hate this man gets is crazy.

 

A win is a win is a win.

44-0

You deal with it.:hi:

 

Chavez is a greater W than anything Mayweather has as far as decisive victories go over ATG opponents. A "controversial" W over Whitaker as well. These are top 40 ATGs were talking about here.

I agree Floyd's resume is deeper with the more consistent wins but let's not get crazy.