When its all said and done Oscar de La Hoya will rank higher than Floyd Mayweather Jr

LOL @ only one loss. Frankie Randall whupped his ass in 1993 and then they sh*tted on Randall in the rematch. Chavez was already a faded fighter when Oscar met him the first time and the rematch was just a joke.

 

Oscar and Floyd are not the same size. Give Floyd natural size advantages over an old Chavez and a Mosley moving up 12 pounds and he defeats them easily.

Prime Floyd is on par with a prime Whitaker whether people chose to acknowledge it or not. He would defeat an over-the-hill version.

If Floyd was the same size as Trinidad and Vargas, he would defeat them. HE IS A BETTER FIGHTER than both.

He would lose to Hopkins, but he wouldn't quit like Oscar did.

 

No, he wouldn't have. For starters, I don't think a 2010 Oscar beats a 2010 Mosley. Furthermore, that's not how you judge resumes anyway.

 

I'm not engaging in conversation anymore with StevieBruno on this particular thread.

The thing that put the nail in the coffin is StevieBruno's comment: 'Prime Floyd is on par with a prime Whitaker'.

 

Prime Floyd is not just on par with a prime Whitaker, he is better.

 

No he lost.

And secondly, why are you even debating like this. Mike Tyson would run through Roy Jones' resume - does that mean he should be rated higher? You are one deluded ****

 

:rofl
I was warned by the most knowledgeable posters on ESB of dumbasses on General boxing forum.

 

There is a blueprint on how to beat Pernell Whitaker. He lost to Trinidad, outboxed for 11 rounds against Diosbelys Hurtado, knocked out.

Floyd Mayweather's record is perfect, he has never ever been beat. He has never been knocked down. There is no blueprint on how to beat Floyd Mayweather.

 

atsch Mike Tyson is a heavyweight.
Floyd and Oscar operated in the same weight divisions, although Oscar was gutsy and took on fights at 160lbs when he was a fat ass.

'No he lost'. Have fun with that, even though the whole world apart from the odd few know the fight was a robbery. It's the same fight where Oscar outlanded Mosley by 100 punches and outlanded him in the power punch department as well. I'm not going to argue that case anymore, each to their own tbh.

 

Pernell Whitaker is top 10-15 IMO and definitely greater than Floyd. But he most certainly wasn't superior offensively.