When its all said and done Oscar de La Hoya will rank higher than Floyd Mayweather Jr

2 Great American fighters but Mayweather is wayyy ahead of of what De la Hoya ever did.

 

Such bull****. DLH took the fight. So if he won it would be all good. he got his ass handed to him. There are no excuses. If you take the fight it is on the fighter . Win or lose that is the risk they take. The excuses always roll out after the loss. DLH was such a heavy favorite.

 

Dlh ranks higher than Floyd. When they fought I really thought Floyd was gonna put a severe beating on Oscar (due to his age and inactivity) but not even close. The first half of the fight was actually competitive and yes I had Floyd winning about 8 rds. but watching that fight left no doubt that a prime Oscar beats Floyd @ any weight.

 

Beat DLH.
Never Lost
5 division champ.
wouldnt lose to a fighter like sturm



I am not a huge mayweather fan and i really like DLH(his autobiography was amazing) but to be honest these two are in a different league. Mayweather is just much better. then again it is subject to opinion

 

You can't rank a fighter based on hypothetical.

Also, Oscar is a 6 division champion.

I'm still waiting to hear what Mayweather wins are so far and above Oscar's. I don't want to hear about the 0, or Oscar's losses or gifts. Anj is right in that half of this thread has been a smoke and mirrors detraction from De La Hoya's resume.

Modern media has made both Pacquiao and Mayweather seem like so much more than they are.

 

Looks like you visted a few local Vegas crack houses with unca roga

 

you realize floyd started at super feather, dont you?

 

As did De La Hoya.

 

that doesn't mean floyd carries as well through the weights, and the truth is he doesn't at 154

 

Sure, but that's a different notion than the one you implied.

 

You make some valid points.

 

isal was implying that because oscar took on sturm, floyd should too
oscar's a bigger man than floyd and carries more pop

EDIT : maybe i should've been clearer

 

Yeah I get what you were trying to say and agree, I was just like "wait a minute, so did DLH" and felt like putting it out there.

Though the fact he was able to get that high and still be functional is a bit of a plus.