When its all said and done Oscar de La Hoya will rank higher than Floyd Mayweather Jr

Based on that ill rank Casamayor next to DLH, he fought freitas,corrales x3, Castillo,Campbell ,Marquez ,Bradley,Guerrero.

 

Exactly. Nonsensical argument

 

I have Floyd higher by a good margin, but the arguments against Delahoya are embarrassing, as are the ones propping up Mayweather.

 

:yikes

Nothing stands in the way of Oscar. :deal

 

Casamayor has wins over which ATGs??

 

Most of those names don't belong with these: Chavez, Whitaker, Hopkins, Pac, FLoyd, Mosley, Trinidad, etc.

 

I wish I wasn't a ***** or else I'd sig that line

 

I think *****s here are just seeking to add comedic value now lol

 

Most were predicting Marquez to be competitive. I expected 8-4. The complete and utter domination when taking into accout Marquez destruction of Pacquiao is still unreal

 

Damn, I love it. *****s asking who Oscar fought in their prime and at what weight. The man has fighters like Trinidad, Mosley x2, Vargas, and Hopkins on his resume.

Who has Floyd fought recently? Marquez, Ortiz, Mosley, and Guerrero?

Oscars performance against Trinidad is better then anything Floyd has done at WW. Vargas and Mosley were juicing but that didn't have Oscar scared for his health. Hell he fought a roided Mosley twice. Say he didn't win the second time if you want. Yet, years later a old, shot, numerously defeated Mosley is Floyds best win at WW.

 

I'm referring more to what prime/peak hall of fame fighters did Oscar beat. I know Tito and the case can be made for Shane. But in regards to Shane, was 154 really his best weight? What did Mosley do at 154 that was off the charts? Other than that he fought Hopkins (lost), Floyd (lost), and Manny (lost). Who else was there? Oh I forgot about Gatti. He moved Gatti up though. I'm not saying this to **** on Oscar because I already said in this thread that Oscar has a better resume than Floyd.

 

Grasping for straws.

 

Was 154 Oscar's best weight?

 

Ermm you guys are so dumb. Floyd beat Robert Guerrero, he's better than Oscar as a result. These opponents, Ndou, Baldomir, Guerrero - ****ing hell, wow. TMT Ya Dig!! Blat!!

 

You actually picked Marquez to nick 4 rounds?! After going through hell with Diaz?

Hell I wouldn't pick Marquez to nick 2 rounds even now. Didn't pick him to nick 2 even back then