Am I the only one here who agrees with 117-111?

I gave round 10 to Malignaggi, but I don't think 117-111 was that bad. AB did win the fight convincingly after round 4.

 

Paulie did clearly win rounds 1, 2 and 4. rounds 3, 5, 10, 11 and 12 could have gone either way.

Any 117-111 score card is extremely biased towards Broner.

 

It could be argued either way. I could see scoring 3, 5, and 10 even, but I thought 11 and 12 were AB rounds.

 

well Prime Ricky would have mauled him I think we can all agree

 

You only score clean shots

 

Paulie's punches were totally ineffective, if your score punches that land everywhere but the head or body, Paulie wins in a landslide, but the call them effective punches for a reason and Broner clearly landed the more effective punches.

I don't put too much on the scoring as long as the right guy wins, which in this case was Broner. Paulie didn't help his case by going backwards the entire fight, it gives the illusion that he was the inferior fighter, which in this case he was.

In my opinion there's no controversy and it was far from a robbery.

 

None. That wasn't my point. He was throwing volume punches and out working Broner. I was attacking the argument that power punches should have won Broner the fight. If he was hurting Paulie then I would say he should have won but his power punches were not effective. After all, a power punch is just any punch besides a jab, it doesn't have to be "powerful" and is often misleading. Paulie's pace and output should have been enough to win him the fight. He fought his fight and neutralized Broner.

 

I agree. I didn't score round 3 and 5 even, I thought AB won them, but I could see how someone scored 3 even. Or 10. I gave 10 to Paulie, but yeah i thought 11 and 12 Broner won clearly. You could tell Paulie was just trying to survice in the 12th. Something was hurting, either his head or his hand, maybe both.

 

The 117-111 is about right. Didn't bother to score felt it was something like 116-112. The fight was competitive but Broner was winning based on clean effective punching.

 

I thought Pauli did ok in the 12th myself. He has cheen and hearth nobody can take that away from him.

 

What are you talking about. In round 3, he stumbled on a left hook at the begin of the round and received all the hard clean shots.

 

disgrace. i thought Broner edged it, but that card was too wide.

 

It was no more a disgrace than someone having Paulie winning.

 

:deal