Who's the GOAT at SMW?

But......

He was smoked by Jones at SMW. I just can't seem to look past that.

That speaks volumes in the argument.

 

He was close to death!

 

But everyone knows bailey how much you love Calzaghe so your opinion is essentially pointless because you are so biased. For me at the moment it is Joe, but ward will eventually overtake him

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1m7RV55wrCE


He didn't look dead to me. Everyone likes to **** on that fight now, but at the time, it was one of the greatest.

 

It was well known Toney was struggling with the weight, it happened in previous bouts, it's mention in the interview you posted and Ray Leonard mentioned it in an interview before the fight. He gained 17lbs after the weight in which is a huge amount for any fighter to gain.

 

So he was struggling with weight, it was still a great win for Roy Jones.

Funny his weight struggles didn't stop him from becoming a MW or SMW world champion, and one of the pound for pound best.. But since he lost to Roy, it has to be an excuse.

 

atsch:nut Says it all there. Surprised Atberrys SMW top 10 doesnt read something like Eubank, Benn, Watson, Holmes, Thornton....:yep
You failed to say how you have your number 1 above your number 6 , so I would love to know how you got all the others (2-5) above 6.
This will be good

As MR pointed out to you. Jones beat toney. Tell me, what was this big Toney SMW win and skillfull opponent?

So if you can counter any point, you would have done so.
I dont see a point in being bias because facts will catch you out, and thats where I constantly pwn you guys, because I comment on a weight that I have watched and followed from day one, giving me better insight than someone who has not followed it for any more than 10 years and I guess by your comment, less than that.
At least with Atberry, I know he has been watching also even though he is Eubank through and through without being able to justify, and as said if you cant justify, you get caught out

 

Incidentally number 6 on his list beat number 1, and number 7 beat number 3 in head to head matches.:huh Keep in mind number 6 and 7 were both undefeated at this weight, so there would be no losses canceling out their head to head superiority over 1 and 3.

Let me guess, those wins are meaningless due to weight issues.

 

Damn it Serge! I would like to have heard your opinion on this topic.

 

Have you got your own tv show yet?

Joe would never have gotten in the ring with a prime version of Roy, let alone beaten him.

I've owned you twice on who Roy supposedly ducked, but here you are again.

Ignoring facts, and repeating what you think is true, doesn't make it so.

You are deluded!

 

The problem is that Ward's got no P4P opposition. Golovkin? Groves if he beats Froch, has potential. But Ward ain't young either.

Unfortunate for Ward or fortunate depending on your POV

 

Absolutely appalling list. :roflatsch