Fights that ruined a fighter's career, win or lose?

gumbo2176 · Sep 3, 2013

Luis Resto vs. Billy Collins Collins never fought again after the beating he got by Resto with the padding removed from his gloves by Panama Lewis.

Michael Spinks vs. Mike Tyson Feet twitching KO's are not a good thing

Mike Tyson vs. Robin Givens She took his manhood on national TV.

Hamhead vs. Barrerra Hamhead fought 1 more time and hung them up.

Carlos Monzon vs. Tony Licata Tony was a local favorite and after the Monzon fight he was never the same.

Sug3 · Sep 3, 2013

Tyson vs Douglas-Tyson
Vargas vs Trinidad-Vargas
Mosley vs Forrest-Mosley
Trinidad vs Hopkins-Trinidad
Trinidad vs Reid-Reid
Arguello vs Pryon-Arguello
Barrera vs Hamed-Hamed
Jones vs Tarver-Jones
Berto vs Ortiz-Both
Forrest vs Mayorga-Forrest

Sweet Jones · Sep 3, 2013

Hector Camacho vs. Edwin Rosario

DoinDamage · Sep 3, 2013

Golota ruined Bowe both "high and low" in their two fights.

Momus · Sep 3, 2013

Lewis-Ruddock
Lewis-Golota
Lewis-Grant

MrFoFody · Sep 3, 2013

macalpinerules said: ↑

I'm recent memory
Ward definitely ruined Dawson.
Margarito took a lot out of Cotto.
Salido ended Juanma's career.
Donaire brought Montiel to ruination.
Pacquiao retired De La Hoya.
Pacquiao extracted Hatton's Soul.
Pacquiao made Clottey no longer interested in boxing.
Pacquiao turned Margarito into a pirate and essentially ended his career.
Pacquiao Nearly murdered David Diaz.
I feel Confident saying that Garcia took Whatever spirit Prescott left in Khan.
Hopkins put Pavlik's desire in a duffel bag and walked away with it.
Pavlik left Taylor and entirely different person, he was never the same again.
Hopkins Put a halt to the steam engine that was Felix Trindad and it never got going again.
Martinez performed a demolition on Paul Williams spirit
Sergey Dzinzurik was a very talented Middleweight until Martinez beat him like an addiction he was sick of.
I honestly believe Provodnikov has taken something very dear and personal to Bradley: in Christianity they call it the soul.
I think Floyd beat the warrior spirit out of Gatti in a way no one had ever done.
Tito Definitely took From Vargas all of the ATG potential he had, it was clear Bargas was never gonna be the same.
Tito murdered Joppy's career.
Despite having some nice moments since then, it's safe to say that because of Kosta, Zab never reached his full potential.
Ortiz turned it around and finally played the role of soul snatched against berto.
Froch emptied Bute of all the things that make a man's life worth living.
Tarver put an end to one of the greatest and most feared boxers in recent memory.
Mayorga knocked out Vernon's potential to be great.
You may disagree, but the beating Pacquiao put on Barerra in ther first fight ended him as an elite.
I liked Jirov a lot, but Toney left me with nothing to like anymore.
I think Corales ended Castillo's elite status, he was never the same after that series.
Nate Campbell shut the lights out on a streaking star by the name Juan Diaz.
I think it's fair to say that Maidana took Ortiz's confidence.
There is no doubt in my mind that Donaire is ruined.
I'm not sure who did it, but Arthur Abraham is ruined.
James toney ruined himself.
Vitali gorged on Chris Areola's potential.
Although he had a magnificent career afterwards, I think De la Hoya lost a ton of passion after losing to Trinidad.
Of all the fights he lost, I think the fight against Zahir Raheem was the one that ended Erik Morales as we knew him.
I think Hipkins left a mark that has remained with Antonio and made him something less than the confident brash trash talker he was before they fought.
Someone ruined Tyson, but I Can't decide exactly who.
There's no question in my mind that it was in fact Ruiz who shut the lights out in Holyfield's eyes. Ruiz didn't beat him down he just made Holy struggle so much to the point of Embarrassment considering how much Ruiz sucked .
Click to expand...

Haha, good stuff!:rofl

This one though, was Robin Givens:!:

MonagFam · Sep 3, 2013

I immediately thought of Meldrick Taylor vs Julio Caesar Chavez, though Terry Norris certainly helped make that so in Taylor's ill-advised move to 154.
Mark Breland vs Aaron Davis (ironic because Taylor who I am saying was essentially ruined post-Chavez 1, boxed beautifully against Davis after this fight)
Andrew Maynard vs (don't laugh) Mike Sedillo -- he would lose to Czyz two fights later, he would fight for a long time after that, but I think Sedillo took something out of him
John Tate vs Mike Weaver (just re-watched that fight...Tate was so far ahead...and it all went out in an instant)

energie · Sep 3, 2013

tyson ruined pinklon thomas
tyson ruined razor ruddock
chavez ruined taylor
trinidad ruined reid
ali ruined frazier(even though frazier won)

UptownUppercut · Sep 3, 2013

Lewis - Tua

dodong · Sep 3, 2013

macalpinerules said: ↑

I'm recent memory
Ward definitely ruined Dawson.
Margarito took a lot out of Cotto.
Salido ended Juanma's career.
Donaire brought Montiel to ruination.
Pacquiao retired De La Hoya.
Pacquiao extracted Hatton's Soul.
Pacquiao made Clottey no longer interested in boxing.
Pacquiao turned Margarito into a pirate and essentially ended his career.
Pacquiao Nearly murdered David Diaz.
I feel Confident saying that Garcia took Whatever spirit Prescott left in Khan.
Hopkins put Pavlik's desire in a duffel bag and walked away with it.
Pavlik left Taylor and entirely different person, he was never the same again.
Hopkins Put a halt to the steam engine that was Felix Trindad and it never got going again.
Martinez performed a demolition on Paul Williams spirit
Sergey Dzinzurik was a very talented Middleweight until Martinez beat him like an addiction he was sick of.
I honestly believe Provodnikov has taken something very dear and personal to Bradley: in Christianity they call it the soul.
I think Floyd beat the warrior spirit out of Gatti in a way no one had ever done.
Tito Definitely took From Vargas all of the ATG potential he had, it was clear Bargas was never gonna be the same.
Tito murdered Joppy's career.
Despite having some nice moments since then, it's safe to say that because of Kosta, Zab never reached his full potential.
Ortiz turned it around and finally played the role of soul snatched against berto.
Froch emptied Bute of all the things that make a man's life worth living.
Tarver put an end to one of the greatest and most feared boxers in recent memory.
Mayorga knocked out Vernon's potential to be great.
You may disagree, but the beating Pacquiao put on Barerra in ther first fight ended him as an elite.
I liked Jirov a lot, but Toney left me with nothing to like anymore.
I think Corales ended Castillo's elite status, he was never the same after that series.
Nate Campbell shut the lights out on a streaking star by the name Juan Diaz.
I think it's fair to say that Maidana took Ortiz's confidence.
There is no doubt in my mind that Donaire is ruined.
I'm not sure who did it, but Arthur Abraham is ruined.
James toney ruined himself.
Vitali gorged on Chris Areola's potential.
Although he had a magnificent career afterwards, I think De la Hoya lost a ton of passion after losing to Trinidad.
Of all the fights he lost, I think the fight against Zahir Raheem was the one that ended Erik Morales as we knew him.
I think Hipkins left a mark that has remained with Antonio and made him something less than the confident brash trash talker he was before they fought.
Someone ruined Tyson, but I Can't decide exactly who.
There's no question in my mind that it was in fact Ruiz who shut the lights out in Holyfield's eyes. Ruiz didn't beat him down he just made Holy struggle so much to the point of Embarrassment considering how much Ruiz sucked .
Click to expand...

good list/post.

nes01 · Sep 3, 2013

macalpinerules said: ↑

.
Someone ruined Tyson, but I Can't decide exactly who.

Click to expand...

No one ruined Tyson. Tyson just has a hugely deficient mental and emotional stability and sensibilities. He was never going to be on top of his game for a whole career-span. Even today he is still haunted. Tyson ruined Tyson, and it was totally in the script.

daprofessor · Sep 3, 2013

marquez/pacquiao 4

TheCobra95 · Sep 3, 2013

Lloyd Honeyghan vs Don Curry

Julio Cesar Chavez vs Sergio Matinez

adams · Sep 3, 2013

Klitchsko crushed Adameks HW title dreams

Ricky369 · Sep 3, 2013

Tito vs. Vargas is definitely the classic example.

But I want to mention Foreman Vs. Ali. MAy be didn't ruin the career. But Foreman's punches definitely left a mark on Ali's brain.

Log in or Sign up

Fights that ruined a fighter's career, win or lose?

gumbo2176 Active Member Full Member

Sug3 Boxing Addict Full Member

Sweet Jones Boxing Addict Full Member

DoinDamage Member Full Member

Momus Boxing Addict Full Member

MrFoFody Boxing Addict Full Member

MonagFam Member Full Member

energie Boxing Addict Full Member

UptownUppercut Member Full Member

dodong >>PACQUIAO Full Member

nes01 Well-Known Member Full Member

daprofessor da legendary professor Full Member

TheCobra95 Guest

adams New Member Full Member

Ricky369 Boxing Junkie Full Member

Log in or Sign up

Forums

Fights that ruined a fighter's career, win or lose?

gumbo2176 Active Member Full Member

Sug3 Boxing Addict Full Member

Sweet Jones Boxing Addict Full Member

DoinDamage Member Full Member

Momus Boxing Addict Full Member

MrFoFody Boxing Addict Full Member

MonagFam Member Full Member

energie Boxing Addict Full Member

UptownUppercut Member Full Member

dodong >>PACQUIAO Full Member

nes01 Well-Known Member Full Member

daprofessor da legendary professor Full Member

TheCobra95 Guest

adams New Member Full Member

Ricky369 Boxing Junkie Full Member