Did the judges score the Broner fight correctly?

Didn't see the fight but heard he squeaked out at least 6 rounds

 

Were you talking to Stevie Wonder?

He got battered from pillar to post

 

Chris Byrd gave Broner 3 rounds, making it an 8-point win for Maidana. He also gives Broner a lecture on how (not) to be a great fighter:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wH78VrKdnSQ

 

sounds about right


good that he called out the commentators too, Paul Malignaggi was talking some major ****

 

I didnt give Broner a round after the first Maidana kicked his ass from Vegas to Vladivostok

 

Broner clearly lost. I'm just glad that Broner wasn't knocked unconscious like Pac for 4 minutes.

 

No i gave Broner 3 rounds at best 4 even those rounds you could make a case for Maidana Broner got battered and owned.

 

Just watch the fight, it is very entertaining. You could give Broner 4 rounds at the most, he also got knocked down twice (Maidana got a point deduction though). Not even the most delusional Broner nut hugger will claim this fight was close.

 

I could see him getting six rounds but I still had him losing 7 - 5

 

Broner possibly won 4 rounds. I only gave him 3. When he won rounds he just won them. When Maidana won rounds he dominated.

 

atsch

 

I did , I thought it was a pretty close fight against De Leon

Nobody mentioned what fight we were scoring.

 

The Ponce fight was 10 rounds, so how do you get 7-5?

 

Ha ha you got me , I was trying to be funny.

I had Ponce winning that one on work rate , but I couldnt give Broner more than 3 rounds against Maidana.

 

i thought they were pretty wide. fight was closer than the judges saw it