Prime Williams @147 vs Today's Best Welters

How would a Prime P. Williams do against Today's Best Welters and Moving Up Light Welters? P4# wise?

vs..

Pac
Tim bradley
JMM
Maidana
Thurman
(name your top WW)

LWW

Danny Garcia moving up
Provodnikov
Amir
Lucas

I personally think aside from Floyd he would be P4# number2, Pac would Duck him, Tim would have lost to him already, he would be too black and too skilled for them

 

Paul Williams was amazing at Welter, if he fights all the the top 10 twice each, he comes out 17-3 beating every man he faced

 

There is an 82" reason why Floyd ducked Paul Williams, lets be honest here :deal

Too long, too rangy, non stop flow that will not let Mayweather rest & outpoint him while at it :deal

 

Why did he lose to Quintana?

 

fu-- i think pac ducked him too

 

He lost to Quintana... ANYONE can beat him. But he has a good shot against anyone too.

 

Because he wanted to KTFO in the rematch, something Mayweather couldn't do vs Castillo

Paul Williams defeated every man he faced, put Mayweather in duck island...don't be a lame duck :nono

 

Mayweather lost to Castillo, failed to revenge decisively...Paul Williams KOed Quintana immediately

To face everybody and beat everybody, is by far more respected than being an undefeated duck, with default losses :deal

 

love the honesty, man. you dont see that here often

 

he would give anyone problems with legth an punch output including fraudjulent floyd

 

Mayweather beats him up.

 

probably corrales him

 

what i like about williams is that the dude never made excuses and always gave his best effort. his kryptonite was the overhand left. none of the guys on the list could deliver that shot the way martinez or lara were able to. the quintana loss was a fluke as he proved in the rematch. floyd and thurman give him the hardest tests but i think he beats both.

 

What's the biggest fluke, losing a unanimous decision to a fighter or ko'ing that fighter in the first round?