If your list of fighters who you would make favorites over Floyd at 140 or 130 is bigger than just a handful, I believe you are letting personal disdain cloud your judgement. Arguello has a better shot than most. But I still would pick Floyd UD and it wouldn't be one that I'd have to really think about.
If you like to see boxers who jab and throw the classic left jab, straight right 1-2 combination, then do yourself a favor and watch some Alexis Arguello video. Both his fights at LWW with Aaron Pryor are classics. You'll also get to see a real boxing swarmer at work (Pryor) and never make the mistake of thinking of Calzaghe as a swarmer again. :yep
The reasons why people think Floyd would lose every fantasy fight is stupid.. 45-0 in real life and 0-2000 in fantasy fights...
Floyd was the hunter back then, now he is the hunted. Since he cannot fight everyone at once he is ducking. Lol. I agree with you in your prediction; Floyd by hardfought ud
Arguello was a great fighter but I would have to go for Money Mayweather at his best against Arguello at his best. To much variety.
why are we throwing in the arguello that faced pryor when he was past his best then.. hardly seems fair. prime for prime or nothing!
Floyd had an interview with Larry King before the RG fight when Larry asked him "if he could have a fight anyone who would it be?' and Floyd told Him Alexis and Larry didnt know who he was and floyd said he was amazing. Floyd and Alexis at 130 would be an excellent fight I just think Floyd was just to fast at 130, feet, body, head he got hit a lot more than now but still was well above most on Defense