RING P4P Ratings

Looking at your location, I wonder why you'd think that.

:rofl

 

1.PBF
2.Ward
3.Rigo
4.Martinez
5.Pac
6.Garcia
7.Bradley
8.JMM
9.Froch
10.Hopkins

 

wtf,
i can ubderstand paqs name gets him in the top 5 BUT how the phuck
is jmm and bradley anywhere close to top 10 p4pers.

i can think of 20 fighters currently way better than them and 10 fighters
around their weight that pummel both of them.

l,fao and froch in a top 10. LMFAO

 

Expose your IP and you're same brittard with 300 alts.

 

I only need one account to realize and say that Vlad belongs on no one's p4p list. That his "skill" is his size and without his size he is nothing. :yep

 

with all the 'catchweight' fights he has had Pacquiao should not bee on the list. Real P4P fighters can move up or down and not need silly 'catchweights' to protect them.

 

My list on first thought

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Pacquaio
4. Rigo
5. Wlad
6. JMM
7. Bradley
8. Martinez
9. R Gonzalez
10. Froch


It's difficult to know where to put JMM and Bradley. Its also coming to the stage where Ward mightn't get his automatic #2 spot due to inactivity: He hasn't had a really high quality win since the super 6. Promotion troubles or not, he needs to get fighting soon to hold his spot.

I had D Garcia in there but he essentially lost to Herrera, and Donaire hasn't looked good since 2012 so I don't think either should be rated above Gonzalez for example. Froch looked to be dominated in his last fight but he shows great chin, heart and determination and he did officially win so he deserves his place for the moment, lets see how the rematch goes.

Martinez is also hard to place: I would take him out as I think GGG is now top dog at MW but it's too harsh to take Martinez out when he hasn't lost and his wins are still better than GGG's.

HM's to Mikey Garcia and Adonis Stevenson, who are close to the top 10 also.

 

I'd have it something like
1.F Mayweather(Lineal JMW Champ/WBC WW Champ)
2.A Ward(Lineal SMW Champ, could be moved for inactivity)
3.W.Klitschko(Undisputed HW Champ)
4.M.Garcia(WBO SFW Champ)
5.G.Rigondeaux(Lineal SBW Champ)
6.M.Pacquiao(WBO WW Champ)
7.S.Martinez(Undisputed MW Champ, last fight was close could be moved for inactivity)
8.T.Bradley(lost last fight, but was previously rated as high as 3)
9.S.Alvarez(one fight removed from being Unified JMW Champ, only loss to P4P #1)
10.D.Garcia(Undisputed JWW Champ, last fight was close/debatable)

 

Who is number 6, JMM?

Having Pacquaio at 7 after beating #3 Bradley and having M Garcia at 4 makes your list pretty questionable.

 

Lol I knew something seemed off didn't catch it, just goes to show proof reading is fundamental.

Garcia has been on a tear in the lower divisions he may be a bit high his resume should have him highly ranked then factoring in performances by others on the list and him arguably being in the top 10 before so he moves up.

As for #6 I'd move Pacquiao to #6 and move them all up one and include D.Garcia. the last 2/3 spots are always a toss up and though his last fight was close/debatable decision he's still undefeated undisputed JWW Champ.

Some may bring up the Pac/TB/JMM triangle I feel all three don't deserve to be on the list and he happen to just miss the cut. In his last 5 fights Pac has 2 clear wins his win in the Bradley rematch the only one of importance. Bradley has a win over Pacquiao I felt it was close others debatable, as well as Marquez again felt it was a closer win others dominating. Marquez has the KO of Pac and arguably beat him all 4 times but he's 40+ and clearly declined coming off a loss.

 

Why do ppl say dumb **** like this?

Many things tha contribute to boxing ability are genetic and thus unfair

How about we make Floyd slower, he'd be bum. Take away Mike Tyson's power he'd be a bum, an so on and so forth

Don't be a jealous *****

 

Please justify why Garcia, Bradley, and Froch are in the top 10 but Wlad isnt

 

Thanks for your explanation and its pretty good except for the M Garcia part (can't let you off that easy). I presume you rate M Garcia based on being undefeated, having a high KO%, young etc. Fine but how can you not include R Gonzalez then on the list? 2 time champ in the lower divisions soon stepping up in weight again, undefeated, high KO% with some quality wins.

 

I'll admit currently I only really follow 130/26-75, 26 and below I just have fighters I follow like Donaire, Santa Cruz.. Cruiser I know nothing about & Wlad is the most unbeatable man on the planet nothing else at Heavy really matters. I assume your talking about the flyweight Gonzalez don't know enough about those weights to rate him, seen a few of his fights though.

 

Hopkins is too high and Froch shouldn't be on it.

Plus where's Wlad?